Is Turkey a Democratic State?

on 13, Feb 2013 | 8 Comments | in Category: Around the World

Abdullah Ansari

Abdullah Ansari

de

 

“With elections up-next, Islamic political parties in Pakistan are also trying to get attention of the people of Pakistan by chanting slogans of ‘Islamic Democracy’, the idea which has never been able to take roots in the masses. Govt. of Justice and Development Party in Egypt, led by Tayyab Erdogen is often presented as a role model by these Islamic democratic parties in Pakistan. These parties believe and promote that Justice and Development Party (AKP) is fulfilling the job of implementing Islam as a system of life by reforming current constitution in a democratic manner. They think that AKP is perfectly putting the idea of ‘Democratic Islam’ in practice in Turkey and slowly and gradually, one day, AKP will turn Turkey into Islamic State that was formed in Madina. AKP, for them, has successfully fused Democracy and Islam and their achievement is a big boost to the call of Islamic Democracy in Pakistan.

 

However, a closer look at Turkey’s current constitution is more than enough to clear all the mist about implementation of Islam as a system of life in Turkey. With almost five years in office, AKP’s ‘Islamized’ Turkey is nothing but a practical joke. Under this ‘Islamist’ govt., there are around 3,000 brothels that are regulated by government. Prostitutes pay tax to this ‘Islamist’ govt. from their ‘halal’ income. Besides govt. operated brothels, there are a large number of brothels which are privately owned and also contribute to national tax with their ‘halal’ income.

 

Sale and consumption of Alcohol is another feature of ‘Islamic’ regime of Turkey. They have even surpassed ‘Kaafir’ USA in this matter as the legal age to purchase alcohol in Turkey is 18; this is lower than the legal drinking age in the ‘Kaafir’ USA. It seems that five years in office for ‘Islamic’ AKP are not enough for them to understand and implement Islamic laws about alcohol; after all, they are implementing Islamic laws gradually. All this bru-ha-ha about Turkey being an ‘Islamic’ state is nothing but a fairy tale.

Friendly relationship with Israel is a corner stone of foreign policy of ‘Islamic state of Turkey’. Prime Minister Tayyab Erdogan visited Israel in 2005 offering to serve as a Middle East peace mediator and looking to build up trade and military ties. Erdogan also laid a wreath at the Holocaust memorial, Yad Vashem. He mentioned that Iran’s nuclear ambitions are a threat not just to Israel but to ‘the entire world’. Economic ties between ‘Islamic’ Turkey and Israel are also very healthy as Turkey is the sixth-largest export destination for Israel. Keeping the issue of Palestine in mind, calling Turkey a model Islamic state shows either lack of general knowledge or complete intellectual bankruptcy as there is no way an Islamic State can have any kind of ties with state like Israel. Romance of ‘Islamic’ AKP’s Turkey with Israel is not limited to economic treaties; these two countries also share many military treaties.

 

Gaza issue, that pops up after every six months or so, is surely a litmus test for any state that is labeled as ‘Islamic’. Turkey was secular and is still secular. Erdogen’s wife may use scarf but it is not enough to declare Turkey an ‘Islamic’ state although such action have been used repeatedly to confuse masses about implementation of Islam as a system of life.

 

For those who are fascinated by the slogans of ‘Islamic Democracy’ and looking at Turkey as a model, they need to look into details and believe me, it doesn’t require a genius to conclude that current regime of Turkey has nothing to do with Islam as a system of life



You might also like:

  • Ali

    Nice attempt at analysis but, Mr Ansari totally missed the big picture. He Really ought to know more about islam before commenting on somethinig.

  • M.Saeed

    “—Justice and Development Party in Egypt, led by Tayyab Erdogen”?

    But, it isTayyip Erdogan and he is the ptesent prime Muinister of Turkey—not Egypt.

    • Anonymous

      Saeed Sb

      Perhaps the author is thinking of the time when the Turks were running the show in Arab lands!

  • S Nasrullah

    @Moderator: My comments several hours ago are deferred while others helped jump the line. What administrative excellence!!! In Pakistan style democracy, some are indeed more Equal than others.

  • Anonymous

    …..and now the camel just has to disguise itself as a horse!

  • S Nasrullah

    Mr NASAH: your pranks and your endless prattles notwithstanding, stop flaying Islam. You have already manifest your reservations and your irreverence for the religion. The militant Muslims may not truly reflect the finesse and fondness for Islam, yet the Religion of Peace is acknowledged as the fastest growing religion in the World, conforming to what the Quran said: ” Indeed the Religion is bound to widespread acceptance and assimilation, despite what the opponents may loath and fret”.

  • NASAH (USA)

    “Is Turkey a democratic state” — what a Krazy Kuestion!

  • Anonymous

    I think there is some confusion here, AKP never claimed to be bringing Khilafat or some ideal Islamic system even though this may be there ultimate goal. If a true Islamic state was simply based on banning Alcohol and not having relations with Israel wouldn’t beloved Pakistan be high on that list? Yet we all know the reality. AKP are gradualists just as the Prophet of Islam. Banning alcohol wasn’t the first command of the Quran it was belief in God. For the first time since it’s founding Turkey has been wrestled back from extreme secularists, obviously it will take time for their culture to change. In any case they are a highly educated, industrialized society where people’s lives and property are safer than most others. Take a look at the Maqasid (objectives) of Shariah and Turkey is doing quite well. Just because you’re based in Saudi Arabia doesn’t mean your articles should be biased towards Saudi Arabia as a model.|

    Also, Turkey broke relations with Israel after the Maramara Incident, something completely missed by this flawed article. Gosh maybe this is why Engineers don’t get into politics. Hopefully I’ll have a degree in both.

    H A
    MA International Affairs University of Georgia, USA

thenews blog archive

Recent Bloggers

Syed Shahzad AlamSyed Shahzad Alam
A content developer at Jang Group of Companies...
Hassam khanHassam khan
An established media professional who has been attached with some of the largest...
Adnan BalochAdnan Baloch
Freelance blogger and writer...
Rabia Ahmed SikandarRabia Ahmed Sikandar
A contributor for The News/Geo blogs...
Ashar ZaidiAshar Zaidi
A Sports correspondent at Geo New...
Hasan Ahmed AnsariHasan Ahmed Ansari
Pop Culture Junkie, Cinephile, Comic Book Buff, Bookworm and aspiring Filmmake...
Madeeha IshtiaqueMadeeha Ishtiaque
The content writer & person-in-charge of the The News/Geo International Blog...
Mansoor Ali KhanMansoor Ali Khan
A GEO News Anchor.....
Write a blog
Most...

Poll

Do you think peace talks with Taliban would be of any use?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Facebook Activity

Comments n Discussion