Were Those Not Humans who were Killed?

on 1, Feb 2012 | 18 Comments | in Category: Debate Desk

Madeeha Ishtiaque

Madeeha Ishtiaque

SECTARIAN VIOLENCE

Hath not a Jew hands, organs, dimensions, senses, affections, passions? Fed with the same food, hurt with the same weapons, subject to the same diseases, healed by the same means, warmed and cooled by the same winter and summer as a Christian is? If you prick us, do we not bleed? If you tickle us, do we not laugh? If you poison us, do we not die? And if you wrong us, shall we not revenge? 

 

 

 

Listening to a bunch of kids reading out these scathing lines from Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice with all the bitterness and hatred words can contain, only allowed me to draw parallels between the discrimination and bias in the 17th century English society against the Jews and the sectarian fanaticism clutching our society since forever. Is it hard for any one here to conjure up a perennial list of racial killings and acts of violence that have scarred our society for long? I bet No. What’s painfully ironic is that we do not co-exist or are up against  Jews or people practising any other religion but we are blood hungry for our very own brothers. Forget about the noble ideals of brotherhood and solidarity, religious fanaticism has even crucified our basic humanity, which accounts a great deal for the recent barbaric killings in Karachi.

 

 

 

The rise of the unrest in Karachi this week is only a precursor of the humanitarian disaster in the weeks to come. Beginning with Ahle-Sunnat’s wal Jammat’s legal advisor and Party activist’s murder, followed by the vicious killing of the three lawyers and the Former Trustee of a local Imam Bargah, to a couple of Sunnis associated with Jamat-e-Islami yesterday, what is building up and gaining momentum is an avalanche of sectarian violence. However, can’t we all figure out a common denominator in all these killings? Political affiliations. Isn’t, like everything else, religion, in this part of the world, is also ruled by political forces. Where history tells that religion has always been employed as a tool to achieve rapacious political ends by power-greedy forces, it is a phenomenon that continues to dominate us even now and will continue to do so.

 

 

 

Since I don’t believe in evaluating human losses through inanimate statistics, I feel the need to mention the murder of Dr. Ashfaq, a renowned Skin Specialist and a very cultured and nice person, at the altars of sectarian fanaticism yesterday only. With him, was murdered, not only a qualified doctor of high credentials but also a man who had devoted his life for the welfare of his people, not to mention a father, a son, and a husband. What reason a person with even a half-decent hair of head can give for such a beastly act? Was his or anyone else’s religious and politicians affiliations enough a reason for him to be put to death? If yes, then we should all die fighting and killing each other with absolutely no restraint or stopping.

 

 

 

However, where I also believe that it’s more than just a case of fanaticism, and this bloody artwork has a dominant political color to it, our crooked and perverted religious beliefs definitely have to be one cardinal force behind it. Why is it that we think, anyone who is not like us or thinks or believes like us should be exterminated and done with? Are we seeking to homogenize our society and this world, which is clearly not how it’s meant to be? If yes, we should prepare ourselves to be the first ones to have our existence erased from the face of the earth. Old saying, but goes just right, that how can one expect to sow discord and evil and reap any good? – very similar to what Shylock said, ‘The villainy you teach me I will execute’.  My sympathies here are not with a particular sect or community, it’s with us all, because when the blood is spilled, its Ours, whether a Shia is killed or a Sunni.



You might also like:

  • Jhanzeb

    you are not considered in category of human. if you do not belong as a relative or friend to one of these families.
    1.sharif family
    2. zardari family
    3.gillani family.
    etc

    if any relative of these above family might had used these drugs and got killed then there was a chance of proper action against culprits.

    • Adeel Khan67

      i agree to ur comments, but the above article is about Karachi target / secretarial killings, not for poisionious drugs.

  • Grandizar

    Boggles the mind that in a culture which has gone from liberal to “born again” Islamic, the fundamental values of fear of Allah, respect for Life and love for humanity has gone down the drains. Its impossible to believe that a society that claims and behave to be God’s chosen, are belittled and ridiculed by a small of percentage of thugs (i.e. politicians)?? No! Pakistanis should stop blaming everyone else and start looking inwards to their corrupted minds and soul and their cowardice to face evil. and for God’s sake, stop with the Allah-o-Akbar chants because they ring hollow when coming out of hypocrites.

  • Ashar Zaidi

    Heart touching piece Madiha, if we could just learn to respect human life…

  • SA

    Impressive madeeha ….what an ideal use of Shakespeare’s villainous prosaic character of shylock here. .it reminds me of my golden days of university when we used to relate these character with the people around…anyway coming to your blog honestly …this recent barbaric killings sadden the entire city… all were innocent and learned people I don’t feel that they had any kind of political affiliation or any connection with some sectarian wings …this is something very serious subject and it must be addressed as early as possible….
    but as we can see that govt is unable to stop that brutality…..people should be allowed to have arms to protect themselves ….thats the only solution to save ourselves…
    Pakistan is a state for all ethnicity for all sects and communities but unfortunately we failed to take care of each other….or maybe we don’t have religious tolerance…..what we need is to standup on our own to take measures against all this….

  • syed hussain

    We don’t need enemies from outside, we are well prepared to deal with each other. This barbarism has penetrated into our society. No matter, how many are killed in the wave of sectarian killing because this is a society of dead people. In previous episode of target and sectarian killing in karachi, hundreds of people were killed but what happened, people who lost their loved one’s, they moaned, and who survived they thanked God and again got busy in routine of life as if nothing has happened. I really suspect on the mental state of those people who claim, ” hum aik zinda Qum hain ”. I believe that dead bodies can stand up in protest if such acts of barbarism happen in any graveyard but we can’t because ”hum aik zinda qum hain” so called.

  • Zara_siddiqi

    I find myself unable to even comprehend the situation or rather the culture prevailing in Pakistan. It is only ourselves we could blame because it is ‘us’ as a whole who are responsible for the restlessness, barbarism, freak-shows, and whatever is happening in Pakistan. Religion has become only God knows what…we have become so divided in the name of religion, we have restricted religion to only quran khwanis, khatams and namaz…i believe it is very important to make religious education compulsory for everyone especially women. i myself being a women strongly believe that women are most responsible for the illness in our society because of the illiterate upbringing of generations upon generations. And I dont mean school/college/university education when i use the term literate, also religious education also doesnot only mean the obligatory prayers but the teachings of Quran and Sunnah. we need to learn the forgotten lesson of humanity.

  • Anonymous

    Pity your own organisation’s Hamid Mir had not the same thoughts when villifying Mansoor Ijaz not onthe basis of any evidence he may or may not have but because he is from a different faith and he is married to someone from Israel….wish you best of luck trying to get your message across.

    • M. Saeed

      Hamid Mir has clearly chickened-out under threats. He is also some ‘born again’ person of sorts, after his Hajj, perhaps for all the wrong reasons. Faith has nothing doing between these “traders of conveniences” because, they have a burning example extinguished in case of Imran’s marriage and divorce of convenience.

  • Nouman

    what to say…..

  • Tariq

    I wonder what is the reasons behind in killing of people in Karachi. For Instance

    PPP, ANP and MQM also had presence out side Karachi, then why don’t they killing each others in other parts of country.

    Similarly, on sectarian front, all groups had similar presences in other part of country, yet we don’t find that situation there.

    It is interesting that everything happening in Karachi don’t had links in others parts of country. Its means things happening in Karachi is Karachi specific.

    My conclusion is that, this all bizarre killings had to do with the Geography of Karachi and its strategic importance does involve in this killings and violence.

  • http://www.advancewealth.co.uk/protection/business-protection/ Key Man Insurance

    I’m sure Pakistanies must need to think about their patience which they are losing day by day in a routine life. They must have patience as well as need to educate humanity lessons to their nation. Please stop the killing where ever it happens.

  • S Nasrullah

    This wicked govt of AZ/YG have lost its mandate to govern and the sooner the elections are held to bring in new leadership, the better it is for the safety, security and sanity of this nation. It is the prime duty of a government to provide safe and secure environs to its countrymen and allow equal and level field for every citizen in its moral or mundane pursuit for wish fulfillment or happy lifestyle. The very word religious fanaticism has lost its original meaning and motive. As a religion of Peace, Islam forbids extortion of any kind and considers the murder of one human being as the murder of humanity. Those who take someones’ life do so of their psychotic compulsions and have no reference to the religion.

    Did anyone ever pondered the consequences of fighting a proxy war with its own countrymen within its own borders? Somebody rightly diagnosed that we are a crowd and NOT a Nation. With very low flash point of tolerance, anyone could kindle a bonfire with one single devilish deed. The security meltdown had created ideal situation for the agents provocateurs to have the field day in stoking the fire into conflagration to weaken the very basis of the foundations of the State of Pakistan. How much longer would a slumbering nation take to realize the perils and the perfidy they are engulfed in?

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/X5JZPQYDYYT3FQ6CBT7H4LTU3M Zurga

    Our culture is flawed! The sooner we realize this the better. 90% of people in Pakistan are ignorant and would believe pretty much anything said on the news. People are too much into other people’s lives and then they boast about how our culture is better than the west because we have family values and close family ties – I call BS on that one. Stop meddling in other peoples lives. Who cares who wears what or eats what? Live your own bumming life and let others live theirs.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/X5JZPQYDYYT3FQ6CBT7H4LTU3M Zurga

    fascist pigs

  • Alam

    It means that, how can we say we are Muslims? : we are killing our brothers of opposite firqas. we are humans first, then Muslims. we should follow the rules of humanity first then do practice our religion.

  • Photojonuk

    I am an Englishman who has recently arrived in Karachi. Reading your article has given me a lot more understanding about the violence that is so blatent in this city. Although you did not state openly in your article, you implied that a lack of education and tolerance were important factors. I believe education is all about understanding ie an educated person is one who realises that what a man says is never totally right and never totally wrong:the truth lies somewhere in the middle.

    Therefore the answer to Pakistan’s problem must be lie in education!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Nazir-K-Ali/100000107251982 Nazir K Ali

    Your article is meaningful and pointed. It gives lingering mental anguish when we speak of descending from a single pair of parents, that many thousands of years back and recovering after the Great Flood.
    What comes to me is lack of education; proper education, which until today is ignored wholesale and with the exception of a few individuals who care.
    We have to re-design the curricula in our madrassas and schools and this will take a lot of strong will and rectitude.
    We have to start with election laws, civilian and criminal laws, taxation laws and the whole gamut of legislation.
    Election legislation takes precedence because from there the rot enters our assemblies and goes on to make society a mess.
    Salams to Pakistan

thenews blog archive

Recent Bloggers

Syed Shahzad AlamSyed Shahzad Alam
A content developer at Jang Group of Companies...
Fatehullah KundiFatehullah Kundi
A freelancer and a student at the Deptartment of Civil Engineering. He can be r...
Farah KamalFarah Kamal
An education and development consultant with a masters degree from UBC-Canada an...
Hasnain IqbalHasnain Iqbal
The blogger contributes for The News/Geo blogs...
Madeeha IshtiaqueMadeeha Ishtiaque
The content writer & person-in-charge of the The News/Geo International Blog...
Afifa FaisalAfifa Faisal
A recent graduate of Master’s in Gender and Social Policy from the London Sch...
Riffat RashidRiffat Rashid
A freelance writer and a student at SZABIST's Media Science Program....
Mansoor RizviMansoor Rizvi
A contributor for The News/Geo blogs...
Write a blog
Most...

Poll

You can get jobs only ...

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Facebook Activity

Comments n Discussion