7 Things I Hated about PTI Jalsa

on 27, Dec 2011 | 262 Comments | in Category: Debate Desk

Haris Tohid

Haris Tohid

imo

 

As predicted PTI gathering turned out to be a grand event, something karachiites as well as Pakistanis would remember for many years to come. What was most heartening was the sight of young and educated middle class thronging to the scene. My friends and friends of their friends and acquaintances, like so many went for the first time to attend a political gathering. People from all strata of society withtheir  families made this event more of a festivity than a traditional political mass. But…I know PTI fans will hate me for it but I couldn’t help expressing my disgust for some of the happenings in the much hyped up event. Here goes my hate list.

 

1) While  people waited for their Hero to show up in a dusty ground on a Sunday morning, IK was kind enough to make an appearance after 4 hours of the allotted time? Was it below his dignity to come to fore with half-filled gathering? May be he wanted ample coverage of the event and kept the public and  media waiting? God knows if he becomes the next PM, his followers would have to camp at the venue to have his glimpse.

 

2) As the royal cavalcade carrying IK showed up, you could see body guards dangling from his 4 wheelers wielding heavy fire arms. The blatant display of fire power by young men in their mid 20’s and 30’s was indeed a worrying sight. Please spare me any excuses of security concerns. He impresses the crowd by remaking Pakistan on the lines of Scandinavia, Singapore, Malaysia and turkey. I’m sure all these countries have gun totting private body guards at public gatherings.

 

3) Like every politician, IK talks about the Pakistan of Quaid-e-Azam and how he would make this country an Islamic welfare state as laid down by the Quaid himself. As he babbled the rhetoric, I could not help realize that on Jinnah’s birth anniversary, IK didn’t even bother to pay homage to the man he so fondly remembers and eulogizes.

 

4) I don’t know why IK is hell bent on inducting the lota force and making them look like heroes. I’m surprised that he justified his decisions by proclaiming that Jinnah himself changed parties. Well, he’s right but I would make him my leader if he gets a non-entity and makes him/her an electable commodity. Now that would be a change! A man in his 50’s inducting men in their late 70’s hoping to represent the youth seems ludicrous. IK please show us a man in his 30’s whom you deem fit for representation in your next congregation.

 

5)  Sources say it took 80 million rupees for the promotion campaign for this Jalsa. Another double digit million figure to set up the stage, arrange seats, lighting and sound arrangement and standby facilities for the event. If this pomp and show was not enough, he took a flight on board a private jet offered by Jahangir Tareen to Karachi which alone costs around tens of thousands of dollars. IK mentioned a guy from DG khan who sold his mobile phone to attend the gathering. I hope he gets a refund if that was not a waste of money.

 

6) Karachiites had come in anticipation to hear IK address the grave issues faced by its dwellers. Extortions, kidnappings, land grabbing, gang wars and so many ills the city is fraught with but not a single word uttered. What happened to the biggest foe of IK, MQM? I love the conspiracy theory that both MQM and PTI helped each other in making their events a success – one in Multan, the other in Karachi. Don’t believe the hearsay, but at least try smelling the rat.

 

7) There was nothing newsy about IK’s address. In fact, the same political rhetoric we’re used to hearing. End of corruption, better education system, respect for law, rights of the disenfranchised and all the demagogy we are familiar with made part of his speech. Where’s the roadmap IK? We would love to hear you tell us how you will manage all this in your lifetime if not your government’s tenure.

 

I sincerely hope, IK and his supporters will take this as constructive criticism and work on their shortcomings for the Quetta Jalsa. And one more thing, please stop calling IK the last hope for Pakistan, believe me the world is not ending in 2012.

 



You might also like:

  • fawwad

    dear haris,

    i am happy to see that ppl are watching the whole jalsa closely just like you so that they can pick things from it to hate.
    i hope you dont see things u hate about IK jalsa in any other jalsa of zardari, nawaz and altaf.
    it seems you dont have knowledge and vision about politics. Reminding you that jalsa was in karachi, most disturbing city in near past and currently too. Talking about MQM and its activities would do nothing good. Please get the myth of IK. he is not focusing MQM (a 25 seat NA party), target is to get major number of seats. if he gets to that landmark then everything you hate about it you will love about it.

  • Arab_amyn

    in short you dont like IK. thats ok. be happy with altaf hussain your king from london.

    • Saleha_faisal

      lol i think u have not read the whole article otherwise it is clearly written in point 6 that why IK didnt bother to say a single word against MQM(root of all problems in khi)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NGUCCJQMBHDR432KQA4H4YROGI ghinva

    i 100% agree with you haris! thje most notable and highlighted points are 5 n 6.i mean seriously!!? he never mentioned or bothered to influence in future the severed situation karachitties have been facing since months,just a concert hype u gathered out of the weakness of your hero status in the form of young ppll?? n the funnist point is really no 4.how can ppl in late 50s n 70s represent youth?? lol.fingeres crossed.may Allah bless Pakistan,ameen

  • Convict01

    veryyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy wellllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll wrotttttttttttennnnnnnnnnnnn tohid haris……fantastic……….awesome article.

  • Convict01

    very niceeeeee…..

  • Ssuleman_2000

    We as a people of Pakistan only deserve for Zardari, Nawaz Sharif and later on Bilal Zardari and Hamza Sharif. We can’t afford the true leader like Imran Khan. In the current political scenario Imran Khan is the best option. We already tested 5 times to Nawaz Sharif and 4 times to PPP. Which thing they can do in their 6th or 5th tenure. People of pakistan wakeup, if u need pakistan. Khuda us Qaum ki halat us waqat tak nahin badlta jab tak wo khud koshish na kerey. Leave all the media persons. Our media is sold out in the hands of political parties like PML(N) and PPP. Don’t trust on media and just wake up.

    • Saleha_faisal

      i am uet lhr graduate(electrical) and i give credit to Mr. Shahbaz shareef who brought educational reform of entry test system in his last reign which to me is a biggest revolution till now.I would not have been able to get admisssion in electrical dptt if entry test system was not in place at that time…

  • Salmeen89

    This was a wonderful depiction of national unity!! PTI arranged a very memorable event, not just for the people of Karachi, but for all of Pakistan.

  • Aliammar101

    Well written…Definitely plenty of points to take away from it…and Imran is the last hope…If I write a piece and claim that he isn’t, I would definitely back it up with an alternative. Mentioning an alternative would’ve nailed it

  • Faiza

    The points given above are very much valid, but STILL i am able to find something which needs appreciation.

    At least he offered PRAYER (may be to look showy) in front of the crowd to motivate them also that leaders are offering prayers you should too. And that if you travel in big black cars still you are liable to GOD. And beleive me that was a sight (never seen in any other political party of nowdays) which brings tears in the eyes of TRUE Pakistanis and Muslims.

    • Saleha_faisal

      offering prayer in front of crowd..r u kidding???? tell me if IK is a disabled man ? if u know real Islam, muslims are not allowed to offer Salah while being seated unless and until they are suffering from severe disease which does not allow them to stand up ….lol why people are making fun of Islam..

  • Babar Khan82

    As they say “the graveyards of full of indispensable people” !

  • Samr18

    is this all that you can muster up??? On a serious note, this article showed nothing but a below average effort to catch some attention of a struggling author… A humble request to the news editor, please post something constructive for your readers to read. Thank you

  • Usmanj

    Mr Haris Tohid, If you mention the party you support I am sure I can find not 7 but 70 things that not only me BUT the whole nation hates about the other parties and current so called “goverment”…

    I am supporting Khan and I can write the double of your article to defend each point stated above. In short i would like to tell that even if you were offered a private jet from someone, I am sure your would not say ” No”.

    Secondly, the guy who sold his mobile to come to Karachi and attend this Jalsa at least did something, if you can not appreciate it better you don’t mention it.

    and finally, The jalsa starting time was 1pm, it did not mention Imran Khan would come at 1pm. Which leader of this country comes to give a speech and keeps sitting and waiting 4-5 hours to speak?

    Oh ! I forgot you mentioned the security that Imran Khan was having.. I think you never saw the so called Prime Minister and so called President Zardari’s protocol.

    I can’t finish arguing but you mentioned 80million rupees for the whole setup. Did you ever try to know the current governments daily expenses??

    Now if you can don’t post this, you are good for nothing!

  • Jerry_mano

    My dear brother!!!!

    I am not that into politics and all but if I think neutrally about your views I only find this.

    1) Keeping in view his commitments you should appreciate that he appears in that short time otherwise I remember other Politicians coming at the end of the Jalsa till they know that handsome amount of audience is present to praise them.

    2) I am also not in favor of displaying guns in public but what does body guard means if they don’t have gun??? And that is for his security and now a days you know the situation around Karachi better than me. What you want to lose another good Politian just like Benezir?

    3) I am sure if IK gives you the example of Nawaz/Zardari then you will not like it either.

    4) The way Pakistan politics is like you will only vote where your father gives the vote, and you father will only give the vote to his local member whom he knows from very long time (weather he is good or bad). Secondly IK has to get support and as for as I know no new generation Politian is as popular as the old one. I know the old Politian reputation is not that good. But what other choice IK have you can suggest that to him.

    5) What you want to be in open ground with no arrangements, no stage and want IK to hold loudspeaker in hand and running in crowd like a singer?

    6) Think positive bro!!!

    7) All these issues are ground realities of the country and its right to address these, whether he can solve it or not that we can only know once he is in power to do that.

    Last but not the least you should think more broadly in interest of nation and not to think in personal prospective.

  • Anonymous

    My dear brother!!!!

    I am not that into politics and all but if I think neutrally about your view I only find this.

    1) Keeping in view his commitments you should appreciate that he appears in that short time otherwise I remember other Politian’s coming at the end of the Jalsa till they know that handsome amount of audience is present to praise them.

    2) I am also not in favor of displaying guns in public but what does body guard means if they don’t have gun??? And that is for his security and now a days you know the situation around Karachi better than me. What you want to lose another good Politian just like Benezir?

    3) I am sure if IK gives you the example of Nawaz/Zardari then you will not like it either.

    4) The way Pakistan politics is like you will only vote where your father gives the vote, and you father will only give the vote to his local member whom he knows from very long time (weather he is good or bad). Secondly IK has to get support and as for as I know no new generation Politian is as popular as the old one. I know the old Politian reputation is not that good. But what other choice IK have you can suggest that to him.

    5) What you want to be in open ground with no arrangements, no stage and want IK to hold loudspeaker in hand and running in crowd like a singer?

    6) Think positive bro!!!

    7) All these issues are ground realities of the country and its right to address these, whether he can solve it or not that we can only know once he is in power to do that.

    Last but not the least you should think more broadly in interest of nation and not to think in personal prospective.

  • Wchaud3

    Bro Imran Khan is the biggest Liar in Pakistan. He has changed his words and agendas atleast 10 times in past 2 years. Just google his videos from past 2 years and compare them to his new lies.

  • Guest

    My dear brother!!!!
    I am not that into politics and all but if I think neutrally about your view I only find this.
    1) Keeping in view his commitments you should appreciate that he appears in that short time otherwise I remember other Politian’s coming at the end of the Jalsa till they know that handsome amount of audience is present to praise them.

    2) I am also not in favor of displaying guns in public but what does body guard means if they don’t have gun??? And that is for his security and now a days you know the situation around Karachi better than me. What you want to lose another good Politian just like Benezir?
    3) I am sure if IK gives you the example of Nawaz/Zardari then you will not like it either.

    4) The way Pakistan politics is like you will only vote where your father gives the vote, and you father will only give the vote to his local member whom he knows from very long time (weather he is good or bad). Secondly IK has to get support and as for as I know no new generation Politian is as popular as the old one. I know the old Politian reputation is not that good. But what other choice IK have you can suggest that to him.
    5) What you want to be in open ground with no arrangements, no stage and want IK to hold loudspeaker in hand and running in crowd like a singer?

    6) Think positive bro!!!
    7) All these issues are ground realities of the country and its right to address these, whether he can solve it or not that we can only know once he is in power to do that.
    Last but not the least you should think more broadly in interest of nation and not to think in personal prospective.

  • Amber Khan

    1 thing i hate about you Mr is…”YOU”

    are you out of your mind? what are u hating him about. Have you heard all the speeches? Many members already hailed Quaid-e-Azam before him. By saying that i will be like him, and Quaid e Azam was the one no one could ever point finger at and all was infact praising the great quaid.

    Secondly almost all the main stream members of PTI had to address and people would still coming in the jalsa gah till late evening. What do you want to see? Imran sitting there at 2 PM and wait for his turn for around 5 hours??

    Please and before calling these lota’s, do you even have any idea what reputation these men hav? Javed Hashmi, SMQ, Azhar etc.. You might rethink before writing such stuff just to get attention.

    Get a life a-hole

  • Khan Ibrahim

    Remember saying of Hazrat ALI (RA).
    Who said that when you like someone you don’t realize his weaknesses but when you hate someone you don’t realize his qualities.

    Same is that case between IK and NS.

    I am having problem to understand that the man who was popular leader in 2009 polls what made him stand lower than IK in 2011?

    Friendly opposition? I think Ch. Nisar cannot utter and never uttered roses for the Govt then again blame of friendly opposition?

    I think our nation loses temperament and they should make assemblies tenure only of 2.5 years or max 3 years otherwise they attack on those who help in continuing the democratic process–in this case NS is going to be victim for showing patience while leading an impatient nation, and its WRONG. Like Bhutto said while he was carried to hanging booth that it has always been the fate of brave leader of a _______ nation.

  • Imran_khan636

    Good critisism,but tell me dont you or any of your family or friends ever affected by load sheading,gas sharing,looting,curruption??? only if you are excepitionally living in Presidential or PM palaces…Atleast IK is making us think positive even if he dosent do a thing?? 1 finger at other and 4 comes back on you….as you said..please take this as constructive criticism

  • faisal khan

    great piece.
    andhon main kana raja!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AJ2WRO3Y6TXXSFTGMUNAG3KXCI Meqat Adil

    haris tohid as long as you hated we dont really give a damn about it . by the way how much you make for writing this all crapy 7 points.

  • Anonymous

    People with experience, knowledge and clean career are the one that can keep young on the right path. None of them may not wished to be elected but certainly wish to contribute their talents to put the destiny of the nation on straight. Young blood is needed to fuel the wagon whereas experienced brain is need to steer the wagon. Wagon can only run to its destination straight when both young and experienced work together in the same direction.

  • unknown

    Please also suggest, if we currently have an alternative except for Imran Khan

  • Saeed Zafar

    Beta Haris, I dont really disagree with you fully but for God’s sake, for the sake of common oppressed masses of Pakistan, do not start complaining now. Give IK and his team a chance to off set this (present) corrupt governance. It is obvious that TIP is not a group of angels. Shortcomings are there but it cant be worst than the prevailing jungle law in Pakistan.
    Thank you for your kind understanding and support to IK.
    Kind regards.
    Saeed Zafar
    saeedz786@yahoo.com

  • Ovais Zahid

    Dear Haris,
    Nobody can deny with what you have quoted in your article. But I think this is the time to look at broader aspects/ larger interests of Pakistan. I think the point you are trying to make in your article is that IK is a human being (who cant be perfect) and not an angel which for a fact we all know; however, in my opinion he is the probably a better option for Pakistan. If you do not agree with this, then kindly come up with an alternate solution who in your opinion can save Pakistan from the current crisis???

  • Haziqahmed

    thankgod someone has got it right…thanks for a researched based analysis and as suggested, we hope pti supporters take it as a contructive criticism.

  • Khan

    Fully agreed.
    I think PTI supporters are gonna go after you like crazy so watch out. They may delcare you enemy of state.
    Last thing the kind of money that was spend in IK Jalsa is crazy. He could have easily made another cancer hospital with it. I mean 10′s of crore rupees for a jalsa.
    Talk about Change

  • Moiz

    dear author please try imran khan .dont be so predictive and we dont have time and too many options to try .so lets give him support and start trusting him

  • Samr18

    is this all that you can muster up??? On a serious note, this article showed nothing but a below average effort to catch some attention of a struggling author… A humble request to the news editor, please post something constructive for your readers to read. Thank you

  • Ali

    All true…But we have no choice remaining in our hands…u can not win elections with all new faces in Pakistan…i also think if imran khan not there in the party what will be its future.. but still IK is better than the rest…something will definitlely be Changed…Atleast some other parties will do some work

  • Coolfire48

    Haris Tohid, I can answer to all the seven arguments you raised but they are so much juvenile that deserve to be ignored just like a six month year old baby….

    Perhaps People like you never write on the lie’s of PPP + PML-N ….. that were uncovered through WIKI-LEAK’s. Thumbs up brother !!!

  • Waqas

    So True!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/eengr06 Irfan Ullah

    7 Things I Liked about PTI Jalsa in Karachi

    1) In previous jalsa at Minar-e-Pakistan Lahore, other parties, and mainly PML(N) had criticized PTI that numbers of people attended the jalsa were not accurately told by PTI. They were of point of view that only 50000 chairs could be accommodated in ground,so claim of attending millions of people was not right. But later on PML (N) leader Pervaiz Rashid retreated from his statement, and also didn’t resign. This time in Karachi jalsa, not a single party dared to point out the number game. As it was a huge unity jalsa in the histry of Pakistan, which shaked the two major ruling corrupt parties. This was a PTI success. I congratulate PTI workers, and management. The opponents were defeated by a convincing margin. All kinds of attendees were present in the jalsa, including children, youth, females, and aged people. So, It was not a fashion show, I would say it was a unity jalsa.
    2) The mazar-e-quaid ground was filled with masses around 4 pm, and then all PTI team came there. It took almost three and half hours for speeches of PTI leaders before IK speech. Just imagine that people were through out enthusiastic and responsive to their leaders’ slogans and speeches. IK got speech for around 44 minutes. So it was not like that people were gathered in the ground, and leaders were not there. It was extremely interactive jalsa between PTI leaders and masses.
    3) There was no atmosphere of scarceness in jalsa’s attendees, and jalsa’s speaker, as it is mostly seen in Karachi’s uncertain environment. IK was given security outside the ground. In jalsaga, there was no barrier between people and IK. Can you imagine this in Karachi? Because IK is in Pak’s masses, so he doesn’t need security and barriers. What about PM procession towards Bilawal’s house amid 40 vehicles and bundle of security’s personnel?
    4) He gave pertinent details of roadmap to make Pakistan a prosperous corruption free, and Islamic welfare state based on (a) educational justice, (b) economic justice, and (c) rule of law. Is it possible to give the whole manifesto in a jalsa? Surely not logically possible. PTI is an emerging justice party; they are in process of making a competent team to lay down the policies.
    5) The quote by some unknown depicts well the present situation confronting PTI and its Chairman regarding induction of old faces. “Life is like a party. You invite a lot of people; some go, some join you, some laugh with you, some didn’t come. But in the end, after the fun, there would be a few who would clean up the mess with you. And most of the time, those were the uninvited or tested ones.”
    6) The promotion campaign for the jalsa was totally organized by the youth, a change in people’s thinking. For the first time people feel, that their survival is at stake. People feel that the country is a failed state. If we don’t do something, the future of our children is bleak. IK’s successful history of building Shaukat khannam hospital, and running it as an independent entity with clean and neat budgetary/financial matters have put full confidence and trust on IK’s integrity. The jalsa of Minar-e-Pakistan was funded by different well wishers, who really wants change in the country, eg., one person in Lahore donated two million rupees, and record is present. Similarly Karach’s jalsa was supported by masses and through donations from all over the world, as people from various parts of country and world attended and donated for the jalsa. How shaukat khannam hospital was started? How he got donation? Of course through charity and contributions by common man.
    7) He broadly mentioned problems faced by Karachiites, for example, he gave two examples, one example of Pakistani person, who was interested to invest in Pak, but he was kidnapped, and later on he left the country. Since the main purpose of jalsa was to bring different races of people in to unity, so he did it elegantly, for which the credit must go to PTI team. IK is the only hope for change in Pakistan…a fact.

  • Casper_508

    Watch this video of IK going to the Lahore Jalsa. What security? What motorcade? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sRqjgqV83-o&lc=BvLXTSIE97Avjh0u04TdaR-s8Uk_P0BqwPgt0ypsaqU&feature=inbox

  • Mok012

    This blog seems to be more of an anger rather than constructive criticism.
    None of the point seems appealing.
    In fact a person like me who just started liking some party (PTI), never casted vote before can give a solid/valid reasons against each of your point which you disliked.

  • Omar Sial

    Haris, I am glad to hear one sane voice in this ad nauseam exposure to Imran. I too will add to it very soon.

  • Hammad Siddiqui

    There are 5 key lessons from Imran Khan and PTI branding and marketing strategy. Check out http://bit.ly/vhHZIG

  • http://www.facebook.com/xeniumatics Mustafa Saleem

    Any leader or any one individual in the world had never been able to change the system while being a part of it, it is not possible, the system is huge, THE SYSTEM NEVER CHANGES”. If one wants to bring a change, it can only come if you go against the system, not with the system. Iran changed because their leaders fought against the kingdom, against the system, same in China, Mandela in SA, Egypt, Libya, and on and on. The same way Imran Khan had to compromise on letting the rotten ones get on board to show strength, the same way he will have to make plenty of compromises ahead in this democratic system, if in case he becomes the PM.

    Democracy is not a divine system, it is a man made system, so we can stop worshiping it!!.. Obama talked about change, but he couldn’t, because system changes people, people can’t change system. So people, fight for a new system, say may be Khilafat?, if you think, China’s system is quite similar to the Khilafat system and it worked pretty well. Only the eligible ones can stand to be leaders and only the eligible ones can vote, (Ghada Ghora sabh barabar nahi hein wahan). Like in democracy, a PHd also has one vote and a completely illiterate person also has one vote (who knows nothing about education policies, foreign policies, defense policies etc etc). The best past is, Pakistan’s majority is illiterate and guess what? Majority wins in democracy!.

  • Rao

    Can You write same for PML(N).? It seems you are supporter of some other party. To error is human nature. we r not angels dear. may be u thinking of urself. did u see security for PM /Ministers/all Party Heads except IK.
    If IK have personal security why u r shouting? did u shout for others?
    IK deserve security more than P/PM/Heads of Party. he is honest politician.
    Regarding late coming of IK. everbody knows people of karachi on holidays wakeup late thats why IK waited for people of karachi to wakeup and come to jalsa ok. Tell me 1 thing with honesty if IK give you Ticket for election 2012 in karachi can u win? NOOOOOO because u r not known person in karachi/ u hv no experience of politics/ u did not do any welfare work for people so how u can win? IK tactics is good. experiences people with inexp. he is collecting people making team later. Why u people want that IK fight with MQM? MQM have only 18 seats in NA. why IK waste his time and energy to party who is minority in NA.
    Why not target a big party so IK can win. Roadmap cannot deliver in jalsa this is not platform. for roadmap always deliver in conference or seminar from expert peope of party in their fields. which party of pakistan tell u roadmap in jalsa? give any example of any leader? so plz do not expect from IK 100% ACCURACY.
    If as person u r not 100% perfect in ur life how can expect from some1. very strange for me.

  • Rabs

    he is indeed the last hope for so millions like us. Why you ppl are so jealous of his compaining, Pakistanis in foreign countries have showed their concerns on number of occasions that how will you mobilize ppl in such a short span and they are helping him by giving their money for their future. As long as they are not worried how their money is spent rest should not be worried either.

    It is not the right time to judge Imran Khan on such petty issues, you will have ample time in coming months that will demostrate louder.

  • Abc

    Fateha was read for the Quaid by the entire congregation. that was much more than the homage the author required.

  • saima khan

    He is saying for free education and he must know who is with him Khurshid Kusoori who have biggest private schooling system in Asia. Average fee per student is Rs.13000/- per month. He is talking about change with those people who are running their schools with the support of Arms forces.All head mistresses from Beacon are either Army officer’s wives or daughters.If you want to ask the reality of Kasoori families you can ask to any Beaconhouse employee who is working with them for longer period.They are paying to their worker less then even with Govt sector without any incentives. I wish i can gather all those affected people and protest against those lotas.

  • Danial Shaikh

    1– 1bje jalse ka matlab ye nahi tha k IK 1 baje ake jalsa karega , its well understood my friend so pls stop exaggerating

    2– he has only 2 cars in his convoy 1 with guards and 1 in which he came, and khi and pakistan main u know the Law n order condition, Dost vo istarah khula nahi ghoomsakta , life threats usey bhi ahi

    3– he did pay homage to Jinnah sb watch this below link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-u_kEProYWs

    4– Jab IK k pass team nahi thi tab aplog boltey they k ye akela kia karlega, ab jab team hai uske pass tab bhi aplogo ko issue ahi dost, or ye log q arahey ahi party main lotey bakool apke q k ap jaise log party ko join nahi kar rahey activ member nahi banrahey, think about it, apka mulk hai ap kab banogey party k activ member? or waise bhi ye jitne log aye ahi party main they all declared their assets or in mian se 95% k oper koi corruption charge nahi ahi…jinpe hai unse unke assets declare karwaye gaye hai takey bad main hisab hosakey ka, ehtisab hosakey, or dost change hamesha leader lata hai , leader ki ideology ki waja se ata hai change , hitler ko jantey ho na nelson mendela ko bhi jante hoge? yardugan ko bhi jantey ho, in sab k nichey koi na kooi team hogi jaise IK khan k nichey hai ye sab lotey (as per u), magar apko naam kinka yaad hai sirf in bare leaders ka jinki change lane ki ideologies ne ghalat se ghalat logo ko bhi change kardiya, THINK ABOUT IT

    5– Everybody knows that for this type of political gatherings businessmens do support in funding, and for your kind information that guy was reimbursed before the jalsa starts

    6– vo kehtey hiana bare magarmacho ko maro choti gandi machlia khud hi theek hojaege…. mqm ne apke mulk ko itna nahi lota jitna pml n or zardari league ne lota hai….mqm kitni bari ahi bhai?? khi hyd sukker thats it, n-league and zardari pichle kai salo se mulk ko bech k kharahey hai…to ap khud baato ziada khatra kis se hai?? zardari/pml n se ya mqm se??? ik dafa aney do ye log khud sahi hojaege, warna hum bethey haina dost

    7– yehi jo apne mention kiye “End of corruption, better education system, respect for law, rights of the disenfranchised” ye hi to haamre sabse bare masle hai dost… agar ye sahi hogye to buht sari cheeze khud ba khud theek hojaegi, they all are interlinked, and tell me one thing did u ever read party manifesto?? ik dafa parho to phir ap ye roadmap ki baat nahi karogey, q k detailed party manifesto main ye baat clearly and buht openly mention hai k kistarah karege ye sab , PLS SEE THE ATTACHED LINK

    http://www.insaf.pk/AboutUs/Manifesto/tabid/138/Default.aspx

    ALSO I AM ATTACHING SOME FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (faqs) FOR MORE CLARITY

    1– Why is PTI bringing on board lotas and opportunistic politicians from other parties?

    Turn coats are people who vote against party line in return for personal gains. Then there are those that change allegiance on not being nominated for candidacy by their party and they either run independent or partner with other parties
    People will only choose from the alternatives they have for that reason all those who earlier supported other parties and now want to vote for PTI cannot be termed as lotas. The doors of the party are open to all but tickets will be awarded to those who have a good record and generally perceived to be clean and that meet our selection criteria.

    2– Is PTI going to join hands with the JI and/or other religious parties?

    PTI is not opposed to forming strategic alliances with likeminded parties and groups, which may include strategic seat adjustments where necessary. We however are opposed to partnering with groups and parties who have perpetuated bad governance.

    3– Is PTI a one man show? Where are the other leaders? What are their credentials?

    IK is our most recognized face; however there are others that represent the party on various forums. We also have a team of experts who helped draw the 100 day plan. The plan will be announced in a policy handbook due for release shortly and will also serve to introduce our team of experts with their TORs and brief resumes. We are a democratic party that is scheduled to hold internal elections

    4– If PTI comes to power does it have the competence and expertise and experience to govern?

    PTI has developed a 100-day plan to implement when it comes into power. This is a live document and its first version was completed in July 2011 which elaborates the party position on issues ranging from Power Policy, Agriculture, Textile, and Terrorism to Good Governance. Currently it is being updated by including a five year budget projection and we expect this to be ready by May next year when its details will be made public. This is a serious document and we don’t want to rush into going public with unfinished details.
    We can confidently say that our party has the will required and is ably supported by people who have a successful track record in the public and private sector. A group of experts is actively developing an action plan that will be released shortly in the form of a party handbook.

    5– How does PTI plan to address the energy issue?

    PTI recognizes that the energy issue must be addressed, aiming at the following desirable points of arrival.
    Convert the current fuel powered thermal generators to coal power thus ensuring stability in the cost of fuel and setting a stage for using local fuel for power generation.
    Pursue USD 7.0 billion investment over a three year period under public private partnership to exploit Thar coal.
    Replace inefficient turbines hydro electric power plants with more efficient turbines.
    Initiate steps to conserve energy

    6– What is PTIs source of funding? How many members and who are the biggest contributors?

    PTI is supported by a growing number of ordinary Pakistanis, who have so far been contributing and sponsoring various events. These are well meaning citizens who contribute to the cause and while we would want to be totally transparent however in the face of threat of reprisals most donors do not desire disclosure.
    Going forward we are channelizing these sources by establishing a special collection bank account which will be open for viewing to people for a small fee. For the record we are confident to raise over ten billion in a year to fund our political activities.

    These above are some of the answer i think needed here for your clarity my dear friend, for more faqs pls visit attached Link

    http://www.insaf.pk/Media/InsafBlog/tabid/168/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/9111/FAQs-for-PTI-Clear-the-confusions-and-misconceptions.aspx

    hope it will clear your confusion, i take all ur criticism in a very positive manner and tried to answer you will proper facts n figure

    Regards,

    Danial Shaikh
    MBA -Advertisng from IOBM
    Works in Ogilvy & Mather, Pakistan

  • Guest

    Blogger is imran khan hater and this blog is nothing more than just garbage

  • Tahir

    Another PMLN propoganda machine. Blogger makes no sense

  • Guest

    Like so many others who I personally know, I did not go and attend the Jalsa out of fear and security concerns in the current Karachi environment. I feel the author should be more truthful and honest and simply say that the thing he hates the most about Imran Khan’s Jalsa is that so many Karachiites showed the courage and did turn up in such large number.

  • Imran Khan

    we want Zardari again for next 5 years

  • Anonymous

    Haris

    Weak points – 3 (ritualistic) and 4 (not pragmatic – oldies are people too! And allowed to change their mibds in good faith) but an apt critique. Pity the poor Time keeping because of all clocks running slow in Pakistan I guess but getting the silent majority interested in politics may wash away his sins.

  • Tariqdmd

    He has made correct analysis.

  • Asad

    Fully agreed to all your points except Point-2….. Grow up to his level & you will know the level of security threats.

  • http://www.facebook.com/einsjam Einsjam Neutron

    yawn

  • Amirhk20

    good balanced article haris…well done..healthy criticism is actually getting obsolete nowadays.

  • Kulsoom

    err, and your point is??

  • ALI

    Dear Haris, you are not aware of the delayed of IK.you are right in criticising him for arranging a huge arraly and wasting a lot of money on it.but Pakistanis politics is different than Singapor or other countries cited above.If you want to bring change you have to gain popularity.Pakistan is dominated by two big parties,why because they are famous.We are living in 21 century but still most of Pakistanis don’t have access to Media.They should be convinced by showing them something.we blam Imran Khan for political mass but PPP and PML-N and others parties have been arranging rallies.You criticised him for having bodyguards,are you not aware of Pakistani politics, without bodguards he would have been killied.you blamed him for lota’s politics,in every party their are good people but they did not have good leaders,they were compelled to stay in their parties and went along with them.but now they have clear vision and they are trying their best to change the fate of Pakistan.You said that IK is not the last hope and world is not going to an end but we have no conceren with rest of the world, Pakistan is almost finished,suffering from a lot of problems.Sumalia, nigeria, Iraq and Afghanistan are still taking their breathes but what is going on their.If you need such kind of life then u might say the world is not going to an end in 2012.Imran Khan is not an angle or not we can say that he is perfect but he is better than others,we is trying to come closer to perfection.He is not in government but everyone knows his achivements. This world is still exsisted because of hopes,we hope that Imran Khan will make Pakistan a ture Pakistan of our Quiad,InshaALLAH

  • No Name

    Hi, I am not a fan of PTI, but I liked this party in one or other ways. The most important reason is he is best amongst all available. I disagree with almost all of your hate points and here I go with each.

    1- It’s alright to delay event for a while so that all people may reach there and all people may get a chance to see the event whether live or on TV. The people that were not interested including me got a chance to see the event over TV because of being delayed for several hours. Well, event was on Sunday, a public holiday. You must not be expecting your important meetings throughout the day. Four hours in a country where electricity is not available for at least 12 hours a day is nothing at all.

    2- I suggest IK to add more guards to his security team for now. He is an asset to us and we don’t want to lose him at any cost. And for you please try to live in “Present”. He was talking about the future. You forgot the incident of 27th December? Do you want us to lose another leader? Few even don’t dare to do such events. InshahAllah soon this country will be a place where people don’t need guards. Instead they will spend the money on education, food or other things.

    3- For me Birthdays are not that important. Important is the work done by that person, which was praised by IK. But, IK should look into it and should improve himself and should not forget these small things for the next time. Big events, several things to discuss…. IK is also a human?? Right?? Thanks to Allah the almighty, he don’t discusses Shahadat, Sazishain and fake forever incomplete promises.

    4- Well, I am in my 20s and I think I have done a lot of work on several platforms but I am sure that hardly 500 people in this country know me. Do you want him to elect me for his team? Come on, we want him the next PM of this country. He need to grow faster, he need to add more such people who have worked in several ways for this country. He is creating the best team. Have you ever listened any corruption charges on the people he added in his team? Trust him, he will bring the best out of all the available. I trust him and I trust his team. Nothing to dislike.

    5- For your fifth point I can say that this is democracy and democracy demands you to spend money on such events…. This is the only way and other people (parties) also do the same. IK wants to lead this country and for this purpose he needs to advertise himself as much as he can. This is what he is doing right now. Now, think about me I also want to become the PM of this country, I have education, proven professional carrier, can do a lot for this country, but how can I become PM? Is there any roadmap? How many position holders join political parties? POSITION HOLDERS!!! Wow what a breed? What if that breed leads the country? Do you have any roadmap for such breed? Nothing at all…. So the only way is to spend spend spend and spend, people might give vote to you and you may get elected… then you will recover what you have spent along with other goals that you have seen for this country. This is democracy. Why Islam promotes Khilafat? Think about it….

    6- It’s alright to support each other and let the competition be real. Do not act on integrities of each other. In present and in my opinion almost all parties are corrupt (not talking about PTI, have not listened any charges about them till now). All are hiding each other’s back, current government is living example of it. Harris, please try to see this country practically. If you need to clean the dirt, don’t forget that you will become dirty too… Problems of Karachi are all common. You can’t do anything just by giving a speech. You need power and right now IK don’t have that power. Let him play the game and I am sure he will come up with better solution. Right now, can’t explain you much about this point as there are several problems and hurdles in resolving this issue and sadly I can say that it is the toughest task to be completed. I am also a Karachiites but now have left it because of the same issues. Other cities are better… why? PPP and MQM should think about it, what they have done to this city.

    7- Roadmaps are not presented in speeches that are purely set for advertisement. IK was there to advertise himself and to show his strength, to show the sign of change. Trust me; elimination of corruption that he is promising can solve all your problems including Extortions, kidnappings, land grabbing, gang wars etc… Corrupt Police, corrupt rangers, corrupt politicians and corrupt government employees that’s all what you have for now. Punjab is much better just because of less corruption on lower levels.

    IK is our last hope. Trust me. If the things are not sorted out soon this country may remain but the country may not remain like a place where you and me type people can live… Do you want to live in 17th century? If 2012 is not the end? Don’t you want to compete with this world? Or you don’t have the right to compete with this world? Do you know where other countries are heading? And we are only asking for roti, kapra and makan? 12 hours without electricity? Several hours with low gas pressure? I am a business man doing IT business, if things don’t get to normal soon, I will think of leaving this country…. Selfish.. So I am and I believe every hard worker and talented guy have a right to be selfish… I have worked so hard in my life and I want to enjoy it as well… Please don’t ask me to wait for another 5 years ….

    I usually don’t waste my time commenting here and there, the last comment I did for my country was 4 years back when Bibi died and now I am back again to just show what you can’t see… Hope you will approve this comment as it is. And do let me know if I am wrong anywhere…

    Thanks

  • http://www.facebook.com/einsjam Einsjam Neutron

    Seven things i hate about this article:

    1) Its has the same content as the other gazillion articles being published by hostile IK elements

    2) Its boring

    3) Its the same rhetoric eh?? but the message needs to be re-iterated

    4) Do you have anyone in mind that has the potential to become a youth leader?

    5) Cant to Quaid’s mazar eh? Considering the fact that there were 200000 people between him and the mazar it was practically impossible and a security nightmare. Do us a favor, go to the Quaids mazar and say the Fatiha on Imran’s behalf.

    6) those 80 million rupees come from funds. Dont get surprised but IK, Jehangir Tareen and other party leaders are actually very rich and there are many die hard supporters of IK.

    7) There was no constructive criticism in the article as their was no criticism at all. It was plain drivel

    Hope you dont mind. It was constructive criticism ;)

  • Muhammad Raza

    rubish article…. u zardari lover !

  • http://www.facebook.com/einsjam Einsjam Neutron

    Mister, you just disrespected the thousands of people who attended the jalsa.

  • Zaheer

    For me above all is irrelevant, If he is the one to save the country from this great mess then let it be. Our history tels us that we pakistanis just can’t digest anything good happening to us, no wonder the country is complete shambles..” Humein keere nikalne ki aadat hai”

  • http://twitter.com/devilandash Ayesha Asghar

    These are excellent points to be looked into, I agree that IK is charismatic and everything but people of Karachi need practical solutions and they need it now

  • Anonymous

    He did address issues like land grabbing, kidnapping briefly and he will address in greater detail with the passage of time- current & previous leadership has stolen everything from Pakistan– it’s only wise to safeguard plans from such people with elections atleast a year away.
    Why don’t I see such critical views on current leaders- I believe those armed guards were not being fed of tax money.

  • Noor Ahmed

    I really liked it…the views of the authors are presented in a logical and most importantly he has not insulted or abused anyone..great work..:)

  • paki

    well your statements are pretty baseless concerning the current situation in Pakistan. Pakistan needs someone like Imran Khan, there were hundreds of thousands of people in his jalsa, of course he would spend money. Did you forget what happened to Benazir Bhutto? It is ridiculous to state his bodyguards appearance in the event. And maybe your accusations need alittle thought or else some people would think your mental. I’m sorry but this this blog is just another way for you to lure the Paksitani awam to believe they have no hope for themselves. Thanks for your input.

    Sincerely,
    Democracy.

  • Alihassan2250

    jealous ppl

  • SWAH

    Some of your points are unfair – let me comment point by point:

    1) Jalsa start time was 1 not Imran’s speech, it really makes sense to start later. Even it was 1, blame it on the ‘awaa, who did not (ot all of them on time). You don’t invite guests on dinner and start food if most guests are late (?)

    2) I believe that in an open field, having guards with proper outside view is important – you don’t want guards just to cuddle the khan inside the car. That would serve no purpose but I know what you mean.

    3) Are you serious? Did you even watch the Jalsa properly? His speech started with an excerpt from Quaid’s speech and ended with a promise to Quaid???

    4) Do you have any idea about regional politics? Please suggest a young man who is ELECTABLE, cv’s count for nothing in regional politics. Bring on president of a debate union in Ivy League/Oxbirdge, trust me he will have a hard timein getting elected. After all he needs seats! Maybe when he is more established, then he can implement this idea to the fullest.

    5) he could not have risked PIA – PP could have gone to any extent to thwart his plans…

    6) Well this happens in politics, everywhere…if Nick Clegg and David Cameron can sit in one office…

    7) Well, you can’t say much in a 50 min speech. If he does not present a roadmap till 3 months before the elections, ‘maybe’ then you can raise your concern

  • Sabamaraj

    Good judgement

  • http://twitter.com/mahamans00r Maha Mansoor ♕

    Though im a huge IK supporter but this “And one more thing, please stop calling IK the last hope for Pakistan, believe me the world is not ending in 2012.” was something i would agree on :) Very well written though! :D

  • Britishe2save

    WEll u are looking for angles from sky …….that is not gonna happen….imran khan is the best available option for pakistan in recent times……thats it….i am gonna vote for him…

  • T.Ali

    IK is more of a Dictator Metal rather than Leader Metal. Leaders create capable followers – but accepting “Lotas” and depending upon ‘Media Hype” is not a process of making a party.

    MQM at its onset, had chosen slogans and objectives considered vital in the target community, which mobilised the Karachities or rather the Urdu-speaking community. Then among his followers, Altaf Hussain nominated people, who became electable in their first attempts. After lots of ups and downs in the last 30 years, MQM is somewhat well-seasoned for National Politics.

    Some national seats of Land-barrons in South Punjab or Mianwali, a random seat in Lahore and a couple in KPK, PTI doesnt seem to inspire the masses with its currently very vague line of action and objectivity.

  • Faisal Khw

    It costs nothing to throw numbers n figures, n
    V easy to criticise matters. In fact, criticising
    Has become part of our culture.

    If allah wants to change pakistan future, then
    Nothing can stop that, if he is doing this via ik,
    So be it, let us all do our part n lets not criticise
    For the sake of it,

    Do something positive for the country or atleast
    Stay quite.

  • Ovais Zahid

    I have posted a comment a few hours back; however, it has not been shown in public. Kindly publish my comments.

    Thanks,
    Ovais

  • Zwahir

    Agreed with every thing…very solid points. but please do clarify that if IK is not the last hope of Pakistan then what are the choices of alternative leadership who do not have 1001 points going against them? you could only find 7 for IK….

  • NIM

    I think one (or more) of the party has given you money to propagate negative publicity about IK jalsa. you guyz are so jealous of him. No one can arrange such big jalsa without promotion (spending money) . Everything has a cost, nothing is free now a days, you need to promote to sell something.
    If you can tell us any other hope than IK share with us my friend. We have seen every other political party ruling the democracy, why not give atleast 1 chance to IK.

    Be realistic my friend, even the nominal person need some security now a days, and IK is big personality.

    1 person might be wrong, 2 persons might be, 10 might be, 100 might be but not more than 200000 supporters get wrong about one person.

    if you want a change, think like it, do like it and promote like it.

  • Taj Ahmad

    Well done PTI and Imran Khan also thanks to PPP, Sindh, MQM, Sindh
    and ANP Sindh for their support and cooperation to making this
    PTI political meeting a success.

  • Ahmed123

    HARIS SB I 100% agree with your observations!!!!

  • Mustafa Teli

    I do not think we have any other option left other than PTI. As for your 7 points; I agree with you. PTI & IK need to attract a lot more quality lotas to give PTI depth. Elections are a year away and now we all need formal papers on each and every agenda he has been talking about for years.

  • Amirbuni

    so what you say we let zardari and nawaz to rule on us come-on , we trust IK, and we dont need to have a glimpse of him , we want he should perform and institution should work ,

  • Danial Shaikh

    where the hell is my reply on the post??

  • Raufbangash

    i hate you

  • Raufbangash

    i think he is far better then nawaz sharif,zardari,altaf hussian and all the rest political mafia.

  • Umair safdar

    ya right ,people are saying that MQM arranged 1 lack people for jalsa

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1013967075 Aamir Afridi

    lolz. I will always welcome a meaningful criticism but something like that always forces me to think –> is there any freaking mind in that head that these guys carry on the top of their shoulders. Let me answer this guy point wise because his intentions seem to be right.

    1- He should have been on time but instead of thinking negatively did u ever thought on a point that may be he wanted for as many people to gather as they could because he wanted to convey his message to all that would arrive and not just some.

    2- If IK was killed in that jalsa in the absence of bodyguards, just for a day we would say that he was a great cricketer and then would have gotten busy in our daily chores. Atleast he had the guts to bring karachi together.

    3- So if he would have said that HAPPY B’DAY Q-E-AZAM, then it would have been satisfactory for you? What a greater b’day wish can it be to some1 like Q-E-AZAM when you promise on his b’day infront of his tomb that I AM GOING TO FULFILL YOUR DREAM.

    4- If leaving a party makes you lota then Q-E-AZAM was the biggest lota of all. Lets not get into details coz it can be too lengthy to write.

    5- If IK didn’t spend this money, may be you will have to deal with MQM or ZARDARI for the rest of your life and I bet u are not aware of the pain of the victims of these parties thats why you won’t care if they rule you forever. As far as the guy is concerned, it was his sacrifice and IK’s been doing that for almost 15 years now. USE THOSE DAMN EYES THAT YOU HAVE.

    6- If IK started giving you the details of each and every policy that he has for pakistan’s problems in a JALSA then my friend you would still be at that jalsa and would be writing this 7 points report tomorrow. I am sure he is going to find another more practical way to give you details about those policies. He mentioned them just to let you know that he has it already.

    7- SO you want new things in every jalsa. PROBLEMS are still the same irrespective of the place of jalsa. It should be recited again and again to convince people. Everything is done step wise. Stop being hasty. Be of little faith.

    PS: I know he’s not perfect but hez surely hell lot better than those creepy ***holes and he really deserves a chance.

    SO WAIT AND WATCH ..

    • Sadianwer

      zabardast reply Aamir :D

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Yameen-Zubairi/1704766322 Yameen Zubairi

    Imran, Old Wine in New Bottle(one bottle).During the 50s Maulana Maudoodi took out a mile long procession on Bunder Road and I watched within one week both in Mochi Derwaza of Lahore and Aram Bagh of Karachi his speech ( same speech) draw more than 60, 000 people. In a city of many millions now with ethnic populations from outside Karachi now reaching several millions a few hundred thousand people in a gathering is significant but definitely not an unusual event. So far Imran is hot air, without an ideology, an intellectual difference, a plan to rid Pakistan of poverty and underdevelopment and lacks a solution to its basic problem- the ethnic rivalries reaching unpatriotic behavior. So far his reach is provincial and rather local. We have no inkling of his foreign policy. He has no significant non-MQM Karachiites with him. He has never been tested in power. He has vested interests abroad that can be leveraged to influence his actions. It is Old wine in new bottles, so far, although he sounds as if his heart is in the right place.

    • Aa_abbas_1

      Its a shame what you wrote. I dont think you have every tasted even a new wine, let alone an old one. Lets stop dreaming and demanding new news in every speech of IK. We are talking of chronic issues of this and not a TV serial where there is new twist to the story in every episode. The issues are the same and IK keeps telling how he wants to resolve them, whats wrong with that. Corruption & absence of rule of law are the 2 biggest issues of the country. If IK just resolves these 2 by even 60%, Pakistan will feel like heaven. Stop dreaming and stop being chamchas of zardari and nawaz. Elect IK and pray for the best. Let the poor guy ever get the power to proove himself, why we keep debating that he is taking old politicians. Let him take who he wants, we should be concerned with the output and not the process.

  • imran

    Well done who has written this, but always remember small dako is better then bigger dako, and every one has shortcommings lets hope for the best….

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1013967075 Aamir Afridi

    lolz. I will always welcome a meaningful criticism but something like that always forces me to think –> is there any freaking mind in that head that these guys carry on the top of their shoulders. Let me answer this guy point wise because his intentions seem to be right.

    1- He should have been on time but instead of thinking negatively did u ever thought on a point that may be he wanted for as many people to gather as they could because he wanted to convey his message to all that would arrive and not just some.

    2- If IK was killed in that jalsa in the absence of bodyguards, just for a day we would say that he was a great cricketer and then would have gotten busy in our daily chores. Atleast he had the guts to bring karachi together.

    3- So if he would have said that HAPPY B’DAY Q-E-AZAM, then it would have been satisfactory for you? What a greater b’day wish can it be to some1 like Q-E-AZAM when you promise on his b’day infront of his tomb that I AM GOING TO FULFILL YOUR DREAM.

    4- Hahahahha. This is a good 1. So you would want an under18 to represent youth. If he would have done that, you would the the first one to laugh at him because its a country not a freaking college welcome party. And you talk about bringing a new face and making him trustworthy. Irony is that you are the one that won’t vote for some new guy just because hez in the IK party, coz you don’t know him well and IK was famous before politics thats why his face was familiar. Just imagine how much time would it take for a new face to get familiarize in pakistan in politics when it took IK 15 years. IK would be far dead by then. If it was some other country and the people were a bit more logical. He would have definitely done so.

    5- If IK didn’t spend this money, may be you will have to deal with MQM or ZARDARI for the rest of your life and I bet u are not aware of the pain of the victims of these parties thats why you won’t care if they rule you forever. As far as the guy is concerned, it was his sacrifice and IK’s been doing that for almost 15 years now. USE THOSE DAMN EYES THAT YOU HAVE.

    6- If IK started giving you the details of each and every policy that he has for pakistan’s problems in a JALSA then my friend you would still be at that jalsa and would be writing this 7 points report tomorrow. I am sure he is going to find another more practical way to give you details about those policies. He mentioned them just to let you know that he has it already.

    7- SO you want new things in every jalsa. PROBLEMS are still the same irrespective of the place of jalsa. It should be recited again and again to convince people. Everything is done step wise. Stop being hasty. Be of little faith.

    PS: I know he’s not perfect but hez surely hell lot better than those creepy ***holes and he really deserves a chance.

    SO WAIT AND WATCH ..

  • Farooq

    Excellent and very balanced analysis.

  • Asif

    We have the corruptest politicians in the world in the form of our president and PM. If you have seen the movie Batman then we have “Joker” as the president and his cabinet are his accomplice. Any one seeking their removal shall be lesser evil.

  • Jawad_arshad

    Why it is showing “Liked this” even when i disliked this article????

  • irfan

    a bit too harsh, arent you? see its really quite simple, IK needs guards for protection and so does everyone else. Do you not remember what happened on May 12th or to Salman Taseer or many other innocent people around. so wudnt it be normal to protect IK, if nothing else, he is a good man who has only done good for this country. Im sure you were aware that roads were jammed and people needed to gather before they could start. The way the crowd behaved, Im sure we wud have waited 24 hours more for Imran to deliver that passionate and sincere speech which was full of hope and comfort. He made the revolution seem so easy, if it is upto to IK, we might be lucky to have a bloodless and the most peaceful revolution. Javed Hashmi aint dumb to join Imran, Jehangir Tareen is an honest businessman, Shah Mahmood might be dramatic but under Imran he will learn to be a people’s man. As far as funds are concerned, if I had money I wud have given him as much as he needed and it wudnt be for him, it wud be for Pakistan, and its not a crime if several businessmen donated him because they want him to come to power and give them what they need, an honest and sincere government who would work for the benefit of everyone, rich and poor. Who cares if establishment is working behind the scenes to promote IK, I mean who hasnt worked for establishment in our politics but no one in their sane will believe that Imran will ever work with the establishment to come into power, thats not his style, its that simple!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_F7ARKKQLGHVO4TEUP5UGRTHD4Q S.A

    pay homage to Qaid? Please explain what kind of homage would you have liked him to offer?

    It really has become the “in thing” to bash PTI.

  • Totomoontoto

    All points valid!

  • Muhammad Mahmood Ali

    your hate no. 1 is right.
    your hate no. 2 is wrong.
    as security condition of country it is essential to walk with bodyguards. because he is now Pakistani’s Hope, and enemies of Pakistan could kill him, as some security threats are in media.
    your hate no. 3 is wrong.
    IK said that Quaid is founder of Pakistan. i think its enough because time is short.
    your hate no. 4 is wrong.
    at this moment youth is with IK but have no courage and ability to contest elections, so at the moment its need of time to share old and new people. and with the time young in future will participate.
    your hate no. 5 is wrong.
    as IK travelled to Karachi in a normal PIA flight with my close relative. its i personally know of you are right than show airport authorities clearance record, don’t say anything without any prove.
    your hat no. 6 is wrong
    you should happy that our parties is now have gesture to treat each other in a nice way. not like past, and now let the people to decide whom they would like.
    your hate no. 7 is also wrong.
    how IK can give his road map in that grand jalsa. time is short and so he gave just outlines, in coming days you can see the road map in PTI manifesto dear brother Haris

    • Saleha_faisal

      apart from jalsa, we have not seen the roadmap in any press conference or some other gathering.And i can guarantee u that he will not be able to give any roadmap in future as well, He talks about “yaksaan taleemi nizam” while Mr. Qasoori is running the chain of beaconhouse school system in pakistan. IK owed to remove the gap between rich and poor.How could he do that when one of his party workers wears gloves while shaking hands with poor.How can he bring peace in Karachi when he can not even take names of main culprits responsible for khi riots Come on man, be realistic!!!!!

    • Horizan

      Just Shame on these 7 reasons to love!
      Especially 2nd, 3rd and 7 because theese are all false statements.
      The total budget ok Shukat Khanam Hospital is 3000 Million. As per PTI they ve spend 600 Million for Karachi Jalsa and 734 Million for Lahore Jalsa! What a waste of money from a leader of Poor Country. No Doubt Ik is best leader but we should accept the reality which is bitter here. He should not adopt the conventional modes of politics by spending mch money and indcuting corroupt politicians. There were a number of people in Jalsa who were protesting for Affia and there was aperson(Khursheed Qasori EX-Fedreal Ministor) on stage who had handed over Affia to America. Kia short time tha k jalse k liye 3 din pehle aa gai IK sab Karachi but didnt go to Quaid’s Tomb!

  • Muhammad Imran

    You only mentioned a few things that you hated. I wonder how many books will someone have to write about to show the positives of this PTI Jalsa.

    No one is perfect, but many many qualities and few faults are better and only faulty characters(that we currently have as our leaders or other parties).

    atleast IK doesn’t have Civil/criminal/corruption cases against him(which many of the current leaders have). So that is the only thing right about IK. Right ambition will lead to right path. But if you are corrupt then to expect something from you is childish.

    IK is man of his word.
    He is honest.
    He is not Corrupt.
    He is straight forward.
    He is brave.
    He is ambitious.

    And many more… So we love you Mr. Imran Khan

  • Rehan ali

    all lotas in one party i.e. PTI

    • Larab79

      dear all its better not to talk on others as said by Mr Bilawal Bhutto democracy is the best revenge but now we will say like that saying noting to opponent is the best revenge in this world so my requests to all PTI loves PUT finger on our lips this is our revenge and we will get our great Pakistan from these looters

  • http://twitter.com/munib munib

    Excellent piece !!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002387313293 Zartaj Alam

    Well said :) Above are the same questions I ask of the followers of IK but they dismiss it saying it is all an effort to discredit IK. My questions here are where is all this money pouring in from and who is behind sponsoring IK financially? Is some one trying to make IK another Nawaz Sharif of the 80s? What will IK achieve with all the puppets and corrupt people in his team and why is he accepting these people in his political party? Why don’t his followers ask these questions? Well, I know :) we are just a herd of sheep, one walks in one direction and the rest of us follow. Corruption can not be finished 100% but it can be minimized and I don’t think spending multi-millions on stages and seating plans and flying in private jets some how helps to reduce the corruption. If. Jahangir Tareen lent IK the jet then is it not obvious that the same Jahangir Tareen will be asking IK for favors in the future? As I know and so does every one else that favors lead to corruption. The people pumping money in IK’s campaign would like to see a return of their money topped up by interest when IK comes in power.

    Pakistanis!! Think before you walk into a hole again, wake up and start asking questions.

  • Yasir Zaheer

    Its good to see that we are setting high standad for some politician.. somehow becoz of his carisma.

  • Ovais-ahmed

    I stand your criticism… But we all know about the political parties all are good for nothing and corrupt… IK is not corrupt and his track record shows his dedication towards country… I personally feel this is the guy who can make difference… A big example, no one was interested in Pakistani politics and no one cares about about it but now everyone does because of IK. He started a wave of awareness thanks to media as well but he is the only politician who talks about change, change in entire system…. And I think every Pakistani should support him and give him a chance to full fill his promises and Quaid’s dream….. PAKISTAN ZINDABAD…

  • Saad

    Well said. Really if Imran Khan goes on the same route which he is following right now, soon he will find himself again without patriotic supporters. Inducting corrupt politicians in the team and then expecting to bring revolution, is what the real mistake of IK. No suspicion about his patriotism and his will to take Pakistan to the pinnacle of prosperity, I only want to see IK not as a true leader with a corrupt team, but a good leader with a good team. Because no matter how good he is, the current team will destroy all the plans and hopes of IK.

  • IRFAN

    Zardari ka chamcha…

  • Ahmed

    BOO!

  • kk

    I agree with most of the comments, but atleast he is trying his best. and if you want to know the road map than forget it you wont get road map from these people. The only road map for getting back on track is Islam. follow what ALLAH says and get succeded without it you will always face these politician. and yes dont hope from Imran, ask ALLAH for help.

  • Muhammad Imran

    I want to draw the moderators attention to an error in the site.We can see Thumbs up(like) and Thumbs down(dislike). Even if you click on the dislike button it shows like. So Please fix it.

  • MYA

    i am really pissed off ” same old journalistic rhetoric”. They starts off with “Like every politician” then “the same political rhetoric “. cant you see that “unlike every other political leader” he never lied? “unlike every other political leader” he never changed his stance… therefore “unlike every other political leader” does he not deserver to have “new journalistic rhetoric”. no one in Pakistan is willing to do their home and research…

    • Khan Ebrahim

      I think you have some memory loss issue?
      i) He supported Musharraf in his referendum.
      ii) He promised to bring up ‘youth’ and new faces.
      iii) He was about to get hang Altaf Bhai and sue him in UK courts and promised to bring him back for justice but now sab BHAI BHAI.
      iv) He promised to defend families of victims of Raymond Davis to protect from undue influence and then everybody knows what happened.
      v) Hashmi asked about Ms. Aafia and who handover her to USA was sitting beside him.
      vi) He asks other to not have assets in foreign while his children are in UK.

      IK is telling us that he is going to make strongest and best sword out of scrap “teeen dabba tutta pajja loya”.

  • Shoaib Hassan306

    7 REASONS WHY I LOVE pti Jalsa……..

    1- not a single person was forced to attend this jalsa as it happened in past specially in karachi

    2- Thanks god,He didnt go to Quaids tomb and saved time.

    3- 80 million he spend were funded by PTI members personally.

    4- HE brang peace message to karachi by uniting sindhi,pathans,muhajirs at one plat form

    5-no bullet proof stage was set

    6- He entered in stadium with 1 security car which he has right to keep with him…

    7- Salman was there to perform :)

    • Horizan

      Just Shame on these 7 reasons to love!
      Especially 2nd, 3rd and 7 because theese are all false statements.
      The total budget ok Shukat Khanam Hospital is 3000 Million. As per PTI they ve spend 600 Million for Karachi Jalsa and 734 Million for Lahore Jalsa! What a waste of money from a leader of Poor Country. No Doubt Ik is best leader but we should accept the reality which is bitter here. He should not adopt the conventional modes of politics by spending mch money and indcuting corroupt politicians. There were a number of people in Jalsa who were protesting for Affia and there was aperson(Khursheed Qasori EX-Fedreal Ministor) on stage who had handed over Affia to America. What a Change!

  • Alinawaz2206

    pti must address the issues of karachi. i fully agree with the critic.

  • Test

    Baised Article

  • Anonymous

    Bro, Think a little broader then you are thinking now… and stop putting allegations on personalities to talk about national interest… no one is perfect in this world you have to try new than the older buggers..

  • Haseeb Jamal

    bakwas article……You could have done something good for Pakistan or even yourself instead of wasting time on writing this cheap, illogical article.

  • Umair

    Hi, I am not a fan of PTI, but I liked this party in one or other ways. The most important reason is it is best amongst all available. I disagree with almost all of your hate points and here I go with each.

    1- It’s alright to delay event for a while so that all people may reach there and all people may get a chance to see the event whether live or on TV. The people that were not interested including me got a chance to see the event over TV because of being delayed for several hours. Well, event was on Sunday, a public holiday. You must not be expecting your important meetings throughout the day. Four hours in a country where electricity is not available for at least 12 hours a day is nothing at all.

    2- I suggest IK to add more guards to his security team for now. He is an asset to us and we don’t want to lose him at any cost. And for you please try to live in “Present”. He was talking about the future. You forgot the incident of 27th December? Do you want us to lose another leader? Few even don’t dare to do such events. InshahAllah soon this country will be a place where people don’t need guards. Instead they will spend the money on education, food or other things.

    3- For me Birthdays are not that important. Important is the work done by that person, which was praised by IK. But, IK should look into it and should improve himself and should not forget these small things for the next time. Big events, several things to discuss…. IK is also a human?? Right?? Thanks to Allah the almighty, he don’t discusses Shahadat, Sazishain and fake forever incomplete promises.

    4- Well, I am in my 20s and I think I have done a lot of work on several platforms but I am sure that hardly 500 people in this country know me. Do you want him to elect me for his team? Come on, we want him the next PM of this country. He need to grow faster, he need to add more such people who have worked in several ways for this country. He is creating the best team. Have you ever listened any corruption charges on the people he added in his team? Trust him, he will bring the best out of all the available. I trust him and I trust his team. Nothing to dislike.

    5- For your fifth point I can say that this is democracy and democracy demands you to spend money on such events…. This is the only way and other people (parties) also do the same. IK wants to lead this country and for this purpose he needs to advertise himself as much as he can. This is what he is doing right now. Now, think about me I also want to become the PM of this country, I have education, proven professional carrier, can do a lot for this country, but how can I become PM? Is there any roadmap? How many position holders join political parties? POSITION HOLDERS!!! Wow what a breed? What if that breed leads the country? Do you have any roadmap for such breed? Nothing at all…. So the only way is to spend spend spend and spend, people might give vote to you and you may get elected… then you will recover what you have spent along with other goals that you have seen for this country. This is democracy. Why Islam promotes Khilafat? Think about it….

    6- It’s alright to support each other and let the competition be real. Do not act on integrities of each other. In present and in my opinion almost all parties are corrupt (not talking about PTI, have not listened any charges about them till now). All are hiding each other’s back, current government is living example of it. Harris, please try to see this country practically. If you need to clean the dirt, don’t forget that you will become dirty too… Problems of Karachi are all common. You can’t do anything just by giving a speech. You need power and right now IK don’t have that power. Let him play the game and I am sure he will come up with better solution. Right now, can’t explain you much about this point as there are several problems and hurdles in resolving this issue and sadly I can say that it is the toughest task to be completed. I am also a Karachiites but now have left it because of the same issues. Other cities are better… why? PPP and MQM should think about it, what they have done to this city.

    7- Roadmaps are not presented in speeches that are purely set for advertisement. IK was there to advertise himself and to show his strength, to show the sign of change. Trust me; elimination of corruption that he is promising can solve all your problems including Extortions, kidnappings, land grabbing, gang wars etc… Corrupt Police, corrupt rangers, corrupt politicians and corrupt government employees that’s all what you have for now. Punjab is much better just because of less corruption on lower levels.

    IK is our last hope. Trust me. If the things are not sorted out soon this country may remain but the country may not remain like a place where you and me type people can live… Do you want to live in 17th century? If 2012 is not the end? Don’t you want to compete with this world? Or you don’t have the right to compete with this world? Do you know where other countries are heading? And we are only asking for roti, kapra and makan? 12 hours without electricity? Several hours with low gas pressure? I am a business man doing IT business, if things don’t get to normal soon, I will think of leaving this country…. Selfish.. So I am and I believe every hard worker and talented guy have a right to be selfish… I have worked so hard in my life and I want to enjoy it as well… Please don’t ask me to wait for another 5 years ….

    I usually don’t waste my time commenting here and there, the last comment I did for my country was 4 years back when Bibi died and now I am back again to just show what you can’t see… Hope you will approve this comment as it is. And do let me know if I am wrong anywhere…

    Thanks

    • Azeem Nawaz

      Umair, i am totally agree with you.

    • Saima

      fantastic ANSWER! It should be posted as a seperate blog.

  • Anonymous

    Everybody have positive and negative aspects and author seem to bent on finding the negative aspects. The author failed to appreciate that people of all social, economical,provincial and religious/sectarian backgrounds came together by doing this in current times is no less then saving Pakistan. he gave people a hope of change.
    Author and other people who say that Imran is introducing same faces which people have seen before who may be corrupt. Then my friend if you are creating a party then you need people of political background and if politics in our country couldn’t produce good people then its not Imran’s fault. Every political party in our country have people of dodgy backgrounds then why just picking on IK.
    Imran chose the location due to Mazare-Quaid so his jalsa itself was homage to Jinnah its just picking on people for one reason for another.
    The author analysis lacks impartiality, proper research and professionalism of a journalist. It seem that author’s own prejudices overcame his judgement. The author no doubt has a personnel vendetta or loyalty to a political party opposing PTI. I think journalism should be a forum for technical analysis rather than ‘personal’ analysis.

  • nasir

    In there next gathering in Quetta U will not see IK on stage he will be replaced by the biggest lota probably Musharaf as his other party workers were replaced, by the discarded ppl of Q,N,P etc

  • Usman

    1) I would tend to agree with you.

    2) Pardon me but that’s a laughable effort at maligning IK. He doesn’t address his workers and supporters behind bullet-proof glass, for a change. What’s wrong with hiring private security guards anyway? The writer displays his naivety on the subject of Pakistan’s current security situation. Pakistan is no Scandinavian country, not yet anyway.

    3) He didn’t pay homage to Quaid-e-Azam? I would advise you listen to his speech again.

    4) These 20-30 inductions won’t be contesting 1000 seats. Infact I’m positive only half of them will be awarded tickets.

    5) You can’t arrange political gatherings for free. At least he didn’t pay the attendees.

    6)Maybe it’s because bashing other parties wasn’t his objective? It was uniting the various ethnic groups residing in Karachi.
    Correct me if I’m wrong but I remember he mentioned revamping the current Police structure and the nepotism prevalent in that institution? Surely that will solve the issues of extortion, kidnappings, murders and robberies, no? Police is directly involved in all these matters!
    Corruption and bribery is also something the average Karachi, infact every Pakistani citizen has to face on a daily basis. Imran Khan forces upon this point every time.

    7) He mentioned that the road-map for solving problems will be discussed in detail in various seminars and meetings later on. Power generation, Health, Defense, Foreign policy etc.

    I hope this will help in clearing up some mis-conceptions you have.

  • Umairaamir

    Reply to the above points ye to bilawaja k aitraz hain….ye batain sachi batain hain lekin dushmano ne phailayi hain….kya ye jalsa agr ppp ka ya pmln ka hota to un k leaders time pe atay…
    1-aj k dor main ek aisy insan ko jo k system k or power k khilaf bat krta hai security ki zaroorat hoti hai…wo to sirf bodyguard rakhta hai jb k wo na power main hai na kbi raha hai…pmln or ppp k leaders to na sirf bodyguard rakhty hain balky wo jalsy main speeches b bullet proof glass k peechy khary ho k krty hain…so whts wrong with u us pe e qn ilzam lagaya

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002196591194 Umair Aamir

    2-he is the just a leader of politcl party y r u putting obligations to obey the manners of humanity
    3-he is just making his army…u can put the 4th point to him when he will assign the responsibilities to the men of his army…army main loty ayen ya glass ya tub….lekin genral to wo khud e hai na…kal ko khud nawaz shareef kahy k main pti join krta hun to kr le join….lekin jb usy koi designation e nai mily ga to wo kya kr le ga

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002196591194 Umair Aamir

    4-it doesn’t matter how much money he spent on his jalsa…becoz he didn’t ever remain in govt so we hope his money won’t be our money…while our prime minister just takes one tour of Beijing nd resource said that prime minister will go on a small plane to save the money of govt..nd his tour cost 70 crores…while pmln spent 35 crores on Faisalabad jalsa held in novembr…they hd given 200 to each person who attend that jalsa….nd all this money is our money..jo unhon ne curruption kr k hm logon se looti hai

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002196591194 Umair Aamir

    5-jalsa main pakistan k problms discuss kiye gye….qn k PTI ne Pakistan bachana hai sirf Karachi nai…or agr Lahore k jalsa main lahorion k problms discuss nai kiye gye to y r u forcing to discuss karachians problem

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002196591194 Umair Aamir

    better education system is not solution…respect of laws is not solution…if these r solutions then Sri lanka has 98% literacy rate why he is even far behind from us….even I hd to pay 800 hundred rupees for the first time in my life as “Rishwat” in my university even I had no charge to pay accordng to official papers…for my clearance to get my Engineering degree…So curruption is the main and big problem of us

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002196591194 Umair Aamir

    better education system is not solution…respect of laws is not solution…if these r solutions then Sri lanka has 98% literacy rate why he is even far behind from us….who will give better education…ye govt? jo khud itni currupt hai..or qn den ge better education system takay awam educate ho k in k curruption k pakray? lolz…this is funny man…no logic !!!!

  • Asad K Durrani

    I am a PTI supported but believe me your points make sense.

  • Jahanzeb

    7 reaons why i liked pti jalsa…

    1. people came by them selves..they were not brought there like they come by free trains and buses in the processions of pml n and ppp.

    2. people gathered under tahreek insaf because they want to see united pakistan without any difference of color and langauge..which is missing in pml n and ppp who always use punjab and sindhi card when they are in trouble.

    3.people came for imran khan without considering the fact who is in his team and who is not..because people believe that if train engine is good then train can reach its station.

    4.i like imran khan jalsa because imran kha ntalked about pakistan ..imran khan dont do politics of dead people like bhutto .

    5.i like imran khan jalsa because people didnt came in imran khan jalsa in searh of food or dinner as pml n always attract people in jalsa with keemay walay naan and murg pulao.

    6.i like imran khan jalsa because pakistani nation likes imran khan charismatic personality and people trust on each and every word which imran khan says.people dont care weather the ground was wet or dusty..people care for imran khan ..people started gathering there one night before the jalsa..

    7.i like imran khan jalsa..because imran khan never used nro to protect himself and used immunity to legalize his money…i like imran khan jalsa because imran khan didnt talk about himself ..he talks about pakistani people only..where as in bhutto dinner party jalsa all poor people came in free buses with the thought in mind that at least for 2 days they will get free murgh pulao…i like imran kahn jsla because imran khan gives us hope ..he dont use the word pakistan khappay`…he says pakistan zindabaad..and i will say imran khan zindabaad..

  • MaqsoodShah

    IK may not be the last hope but he is definitely the only hope in current scenario.

  • danial shaikh

    may i be allowed to know that why my comment is not posted here?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ahmad-Ali-Khan/1620936059 Ahmad Ali Khan

    Harris first of all i appreciate you for writing this blog, as constructive criticism is indeed necessary to keep the man on track. Now i want to give replies to some of your points which i don’t agree upon;

    1. If people are in habit of reaching late even to jalsa gah then we can’t blame IK for this. If we see him as upcoming revolutionary leader then at least he deserves such respect that he shouldn’t wait for us by reaching there 3,4 hours before commencing speech.
    2. As already told by my brother in the previous post that as we already know the situation of Karachi, we should give him credit for having only 1 vehicle of guards not like the motorcade of our PM comprising more than 100.
    3. It is not compulsory for us to go to the grave and do fateha only on some particular day. Instead we can also recite Quran for his maghfarat.
    4. As IK said more than 900 candidates are going to stand from PTI in upcoming elections. You cannot expect all those 900 people to be renowned but you cant expect him either to clean sweep the elections with 900 new faces. you need powerful engine to drive the whole train.
    6. May be you believe or not but what Mustafa Kamal did in his tenure in Karachi, nothing was seen similar in any area of this country. Political rivalry is another issue but they got all the seats in Karachi except 3 (2 PPP,1 ANP). There is something why Karachiites still love MQM. So if there is alliance between them then I think it’s good. I also explained some of it in the previous point.

    HOWEVER about point 5 and 7 i would agree.
    Where did he get all the funds for this huge gathering? Are PTI workers kind enough to donate from their own pockets? What will he do to end the corruption?what will be his road map? What will he do with this load-shedding? Can they build power plants on urgent basis? there are some questions that he must be asked.

  • Send2tonykumar

    This article is full of shit, sick and negative thinking. I believe Govt. Machinery spending too much money everywhere to point out each and every issue out of PTI movement. This article even not at this level that could answer

  • Shahnawazwazir

    shallow analysis. it is quite sad to see how young journalists of a rising nation seem to be following the footsteps of those grey-haired, cynical, mundane and quite frankly pathetic “bikao” journalists.

  • Anonymous

    Politician : One who shakes your hand before elections and your Confidence after,
    I still don’t think Imran is a Political leader, He’s a Manager a bit different than Shoukat Aziz, Imran is famous for his determination, he has taken strong stances on some very sensitive issues, which will put him in a difficult position when he actually gets to the power, Pakistan he’s dreaming of is far from reality any time sooner, he needs to swim through a lot of muddy puddles and these stances will put him in a compromising position, he has already made a compromise by not talking about real roots of Karachi issue so what guarantee we have that he will not compromise anything else for the larger good of the country,

  • Ahmad Saeed

    May be his team is corrupt. But we all agree that he is the genuine leader.
    Any one who has doubt can think in his mind

    1. Make a team of all good people and make Zardari the Leader, you will find the result after one year. Most probably 50% of the team will be corrupt.
    2. Make a team of all corrupt people and appoint IK as their leader. I can guarantee at least 10% of the people will change them self.

    The vision of the leader sometime dominate the whole team. You have live example of Steve Jobs.
    You will find after one year that Apple might be losing the market share, same team just a change in Leadership vision

  • Ali

    Yes 7 reasons are not enough to hate PTI Jalsa.

    It is not due to this that I am against PTI. It is because that I can’t expect a good guy with bunch of fine supporters/colleagues come out and do all lot of excellent work because followers of this corrupt structure didn’t create high quality people. PTI call for an Islamic welfare state but how they impose Islamic welfare system with western democratic approach.

    کیا یہ کھلا تزاد نہیں؟؟؟؟

    Quality of this system is opponent of yesterday friend of today. Yes we have short term memory.

    I didn’t mean to hurt PTI and Khan sb Supporters, every body has his/her own liking and disliking but the point is with a team of so many ….. what extraordinary we look forward to.

    خدا خیر کرے کیونکہ جب امید توٹتی ہے تو بہت زیادہ افسوس ہوتا ہے۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔

  • Pakistani

    Haris Tohid you are Asif Zardari’s A** L*****R ! You should be banned from writing anti Pakistani blogs, God knows how many swiss accounts you have now by supporting zardari?

  • http://www.facebook.com/eengr06 Irfan Ullah

    7 Things I Liked about PTI Jalsa in Karachi

    1) In previous jalsa at Minar-e-Pakistan Lahore, other parties, and mainly PML(N) had criticized PTI that numbers of people attended the jalsa were not accurately told by PTI. They were of point of view that only 50000 chairs could be accommodated in ground,so claim of attending millions of people was not right. But later on PML (N) leader Pervaiz Rashid retreated from his statement, and also didn’t resign. This time in Karachi jalsa, not a single party dared to point out the number game. As it was a huge unity jalsa in the histry of Pakistan, which shaked the two major ruling corrupt parties. This was a PTI success. I congratulate PTI workers, and management. The opponents were defeated by a convincing margin. All kinds of attendees were present in the jalsa, including children, youth, females, and aged people. So, It was not a fashion show, I would say it was a unity jalsa.
    2) The mazar-e-quaid ground was filled with masses around 4 pm, and then all PTI team came there. It took almost three and half hours for speeches of PTI leaders before IK speech. Just imagine that people were through out enthusiastic and responsive to their leaders’ slogans and speeches. IK got speech for around 44 minutes. So it was not like that people were gathered in the ground, and leaders were not there. It was extremely interactive jalsa between PTI leaders and masses.
    3) There was no atmosphere of scarceness in jalsa’s attendees, and jalsa’s speaker, as it is mostly seen in Karachi’s uncertain environment. IK was given security outside the ground. In jalsaga, there was no barrier between people and IK. Can you imagine this in Karachi? Because IK is in Pak’s masses, so he doesn’t need security and barriers. What about PM procession towards Bilawal’s house amid 40 vehicles and bundle of security’s personnel?
    4) He gave pertinent details of roadmap to make Pakistan a prosperous corruption free, and Islamic welfare state based on (a) educational justice, (b) economic justice, and (c) rule of law. Is it possible to give the whole manifesto in a jalsa? Surely not logically possible. PTI is an emerging justice party; they are in process of making a competent team to lay down the policies.
    5) The quote by some unknown depicts well the present situation confronting PTI and its Chairman regarding induction of old faces. “Life is like a party. You invite a lot of people; some go, some join you, some laugh with you, some didn’t come. But in the end, after the fun, there would be a few who would clean up the mess with you. And most of the time, those were the uninvited or tested ones.”
    6) The promotion campaign for the jalsa was totally organized by the youth, a change in people’s thinking. For the first time people feel, that their survival is at stake. People feel that the country is a failed state. If we don’t do something, the future of our children is bleak. IK’s successful history of building Shaukat khannam hospital, and running it as an independent entity with clean and neat budgetary/financial matters have put full confidence and trust on IK’s integrity. The jalsa of Minar-e-Pakistan was funded by different well wishers, who really wants change in the country, eg., one person in Lahore donated two million rupees, and record is present. Similarly Karach’s jalsa was supported by masses and through donations from all over the world, as people from various parts of country and world attended and donated for the jalsa. How shaukat khannam hospital was started? How he got donation? Of course through charity and contributions by common man.
    7) He broadly mentioned problems faced by Karachiites, for example, he gave two examples, one example of Pakistani person, who was interested to invest in Pak, but he was kidnapped, and later on he left the country. Since the main purpose of jalsa was to bring different races of people in to unity, so he did it elegantly, for which the credit must go to PTI team. IK is the only hope for change in Pakistan…a fact.

  • http://www.facebook.com/eengr06 Irfan Ullah

    7 Things I Liked about PTI Jalsa in Karachi

    1) In previous jalsa at Minar-e-Pakistan Lahore, other parties, and mainly PML(N) had criticized PTI that numbers of people attended the jalsa were not accurately told by PTI. They were of point of view that only 50000 chairs could be accommodated in ground,so claim of attending millions of people was not right. But later on PML (N) leader Pervaiz Rashid retreated from his statement, and also didn’t resign. This time in Karachi jalsa, not a single party dared to point out the number game. As it was a huge unity jalsa in the histry of Pakistan, which shaked the two major ruling corrupt parties. This was a PTI success. I congratulate PTI workers, and management. The opponents were defeated by a convincing margin. All kinds of attendees were present in the jalsa, including children, youth, females, and aged people. So, It was not a fashion show, I would say it was a unity jalsa.
    2) The mazar-e-quaid ground was filled with masses around 4 pm, and then all PTI team came there. It took almost three and half hours for speeches of PTI leaders before IK speech. Just imagine that people were through out enthusiastic and responsive to their leaders’ slogans and speeches. IK got speech for around 44 minutes. So it was not like that people were gathered in the ground, and leaders were not there. It was extremely interactive jalsa between PTI leaders and masses.
    3) There was no atmosphere of scarceness in jalsa’s attendees, and jalsa’s speaker, as it is mostly seen in Karachi’s uncertain environment. IK was given security outside the ground. In jalsaga, there was no barrier between people and IK. Can you imagine this in Karachi? Because IK is in Pak’s masses, so he doesn’t need security and barriers. What about PM procession towards Bilawal’s house amid 40 vehicles and bundle of security’s personnel?
    4) He gave pertinent details of roadmap to make Pakistan a prosperous corruption free, and Islamic welfare state based on (a) educational justice, (b) economic justice, and (c) rule of law. Is it possible to give the whole manifesto in a jalsa? Surely not logically possible. PTI is an emerging justice party; they are in process of making a competent team to lay down the policies.
    5) The quote by some unknown depicts well the present situation confronting PTI and its Chairman regarding induction of old faces. “Life is like a party. You invite a lot of people; some go, some join you, some laugh with you, some didn’t come. But in the end, after the fun, there would be a few who would clean up the mess with you. And most of the time, those were the uninvited or tested ones.”
    6) The promotion campaign for the jalsa was totally organized by the youth, a change in people’s thinking. For the first time people feel, that their survival is at stake. People feel that the country is a failed state. If we don’t do something, the future of our children is bleak. IK’s successful history of building Shaukat khannam hospital, and running it as an independent entity with clean and neat budgetary/financial matters have put full confidence and trust on IK’s integrity. The jalsa of Minar-e-Pakistan was funded by different well wishers, who really wants change in the country, eg., one person in Lahore donated two million rupees, and record is present. Similarly Karach’s jalsa was supported by masses and through donations from all over the world, as people from various parts of country and world attended and donated for the jalsa. How shaukat khannam hospital was started? How he got donation? Of course through charity and contributions by common man.
    7) He broadly mentioned problems faced by Karachiites, for example, he gave two examples, one example of Pakistani person, who was interested to invest in Pak, but he was kidnapped, and later on he left the country. Since the main purpose of jalsa was to bring different races of people in to unity, so he did it elegantly, for which the credit must go to PTI team. IK is the only hope for change in Pakistan…a fact.

  • Ali

    Yes 7 reasons are not enough to hate PTI Jalsa.

    It is not due to this that I am against PTI. It is because that I can’t expect a good guy with bunch of fine supporters/colleagues come out and do all lot of excellent work because followers of this corrupt structure didn’t create high quality people. PTI call for an Islamic welfare state but how they impose Islamic welfare system with western democratic approach.
    کیا یہ کھلا تزاد نہیں؟؟؟؟

    Quality of this system is opponent of yesterday friend of today (short term memory).
    I didn’t mean to hurt PTI and Khan sb Supporters, every body has his/her own liking and disliking but the point is with a team of so many lotas what extraordinary we look forward to.

    خدا خیر کرے کیونکہ جب امید توٹتی ہے تو بہت زیادہ افسوس ہوتا ہے۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔

  • Ali

    Yes 7 reasons are not enough to hate PTI Jalsa.

    It is not due to this that I am against PTI. It is because that I can’t expect a good guy with bunch of fine supporters/colleagues come out and do all lot of excellent work because followers of this corrupt structure didn’t create high quality people. PTI call for an Islamic welfare state but how they impose Islamic welfare system with western democratic approach.
    کیا یہ کھلا تزاد نہیں؟؟؟؟

    Quality of this system is opponent of yesterday friend of today (short term memory).
    I didn’t mean to hurt PTI and Khan sb Supporters, every body has his/her own liking and disliking but the point is with a team of so many lotas what extraordinary we look forward to.

    خدا خیر کرے کیونکہ جب امید توٹتی ہے تو بہت زیادہ افسوس ہوتا ہے۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔

  • Rmiangul

    dude itx your right to share your views..but please dun spread thiis propaganda against pti..and please he is the lost hope so please dont be the part of such propaganda…

  • Mansoor

    Excellent piece . You are absolutely right

  • Saqibalishaikh25

    just vanish away from here,we love imran khan,we r with him,everything he will do,it will be better for pakistam,

  • Mariam khan

    Just one question for the Chairperson Imran khan and his supporters” why MQM and target killing was not even touch, in his jalsa, not a single small word against the recent miserable condition of karachi and target killing, which is the main issue of karachi. And then you chant slogans of “change” pathetic…utterly pathetic mr khan.

  • http://twitter.com/umarnaseer1 Muhammad Umar Naseer

    I don’t know much about the entrance of IK and this and that of jalsa, so I can’t comment on that, but I totally agree with you: he is not the last, but is the best hope for Pakistan at this stage.
    The thing I want to mention here is that I had also tweeted many times on twitter about possible relationship of PTI and MQM, but no one ever reply me with any accurate answer. I think, MQM is supporting PTI for sure, evidences are there:
    Ok, in Lahore, there is no MQM, but at least in Karachi, IK should have spoken about MQM that how they are killing people there; every one know about that, then why is IK silent?.

    Also, the only party which congrats PTI on such a successful jalsas is MQM.

    Then Altaf Hussian always talk against other party rulers, but no words about IK. Same here with IK, he didn’t say anything about Altaf Hussian, WHY?

    And yesterday, Shah Mehmood Qureshi said that MQM is reality, and we can’t deny them, he can not say this thing about PMLN or PPP, then why about MQM.

    I am a common person wanting to give vote to PTI, but these things are really annoying me. If some one have answers to them, please reply me.

    And no Offence.

  • Irfan Ahmad

    I am a rebel. Yes, I am a rebel but only when you don’t follow what I wish. Do you remember that when my party came to power in 1990, I humbly requested Shah Mahmood that I will be the next caretaker of one of the Mazars in Multan but he denied and I became rebel and attempted to get hold of that Mazar with the help of police force because I was a rebel by then. Alas! Shah Mahmood broke all the barriers with his Pajero and reached the Mazar before I could reach there. Are these people bringing in change in Pakistan?? Selfish persons who dont even bother about the respect of Holy personalities and fight over caretaker-ship of their shrines only because good amount of money is generated through these. I am sorry for you IK that you are scattered in Lotas and if all these overfill, there will be a tsunami that will only damage one person and one party and that will be IK and PTI. Open your eyes and come out of Cricket ground and learn how to face the Lotas as these are the people who have always caused problems for other parties or always attempted to fill their pockets.

  • http://twitter.com/umarnaseer1 Muhammad Umar Naseer

    I am not a think tank, but I really feel, point no. 6 is correct, I have also mentioned the fear of possible connection between MQM and PTI, in my tweets on twitter, but no one answer me for that.

    I really want to vote IK, but these things keep annoying me about PTI:

    1- Ok in Lahore, there is almost no MQM, but in Karachi, IK should have talk about the fear of MQM in Karachi people. The killing, kidnapping, snatching and thing like that in Karachi are very well known by all Pakistanis, then why didn’t IK say a word about that?

    2- MQM is the only party which keep on congratulating PTI for their successful jalsas. WHY?

    3- Altaf Hussain, and Imran Khan, both talk about and criticise opposing party rulers but not against each other, WHY?

    4- Politicians from almost every party joined PTI specially from major parties like PMLN, PPP, PMLQ, but no one till now left MQM for PTI, WHY?

    5- Yesterday Shah Mehmood Quraishi said that MQM is a reality, ok they are reality, but he can’t say such a thing for any other party at this stage, then why MQM?

    These are small questions but I think, one should consider them. If some one have answers, PLEASE reply me with them, I would appreciate it.

    And at last, NO OFFENCE . :)

  • Saad Hussain

    Dear Haris

    Yes it was a historic event….and very well organized… This event wasn’t as predicted. I and many people around me thought that a WHOLE LOT LESSER number of people will show up for this event…But I’m more than happy that we were wrong. . 70% of the people in this historic event were youth (ages 18-32).

    I am not politically involved with PTI or ISF. My following replies to your hate list are as per my understanding.

    1) I happened to be in the cavalcade that came from NIPA…we left NIPA at 12:30pm and reached the Jalsa gah at 3:00pm. On the way…many other small convoys joined us. At some points…we waited for others. In this situation…where hundreds of thousands of people were out on the road…how can anyone reach on time UNLESS with a HUGE PROTOCOL or a CHOPPER? Wouldn’t it have been unfair with those hundreds of thousands of supporters who were trying to reach the jalsa gah if Imran Khan would have started without them?

    2) That Royal Cavalcade and the petrol it devours belong to Imran Khan. It’s his personal belonging, not bought on the money I and you pay as TAX. Everyone agrees that no one is secure in Karachi in present circumstances. Imran Khan is our future Prime Minister, someone who is openly speaking up against all evil. Anyone going against someone is…to some extinct…in danger. A better guard is he who is young & active. Do you expect Imran Khan to have body guards in their 50’s or 60’s carrying equally old and rusted fire arms? He wasn’t impressing the crowd…people were protecting him. And he wasn’t wearing any bullet proof nor he had bullet proof glass on the dais…like others.

    3) A politician’s duty is to talk about the country’s welfare…he wasn’t there to tell jokes. Like we have given chances to all others after listening them BABBLE…lets give this guy a chance too…I’m sure we will witness his words…insha Allah. What other homage you wanted Imran Khan to give to Quaid-e-Azam??? As far as I remember, Imran Khan was standing RIGHT IN FRONT of the Mausoleum of Quaid and fatiha was said not only for Quaid, but also others buried there.

    4) The heroes (as per u…the lota force) are the senior and experienced politicians who know politics well. A friend of mine once said to me “Always remember that young man’s intelligence and old man’s wisdom…if brought together are the strongest force in the world”. Imran Khan has both now.

    5) As per your sources, 80 million rupees are spent for this event. Well, this amount hasn’t come from your or my pockets, we shouldn’t worry about this. Rather, we should be worrying about that amount which WE PAY as TAX being spent on luxuries visits to other countries…such as the UK visit back in early August, 2010. And whatever Jhangir Tareen offered was his issue. I am ready to offer Imran Khan my cozy home to stay on his next visit to Karachi…and stand outside as his body guard…with heavy fire arms…anyone got any issues? :p You talking about getting a refund for a mobile…??? I know a lady who quit her job because she wasn’t getting a few days off to help in organizing this event.

    6) Discussion on the grave issues wasn’t the agenda of this event. This event was carried out to see and show the UNITY and POWER of Imran Khan…and that we all saw. Regarding helping each other, an old saying “two swords can’t be kept in the same sheath” Imran Khan is dazzling, Karachites trust on his wisdom. People of Pakistan need a leader like Imran Khan. Karachites are the first ones to do BAYT on Imran Khan’s hand. Allah supporting PTI, that’s enough. Why thinking so negative brother….???

    7) In your 6th point, you are complaining that Imran Khan did not talk on the so and so grave issues while in your 7th point you saying that Imran Khan BABBLED about the same…familiar things we are used to. A wise person never shares his plan before time…lets wait a little and we’ll definitely see the road…not just the road map.

    Grow up guys…we should be working together…as a team…like we were on 25th.

    BELIEVE ME…IMRAN KHAN IS THE LAST HOPE FOR PAKISTAN.

    Stay blessed..

    Saad Hussain

  • Syed Aamir Ishaque

    You love Imran Khan as most do, firmly committed to give him a chance to rule. Isn’t the same blunder which you had done in the elections of 1970, in the movement against Bhutto in 1977 and then you again repeatedly misjudged leaders in elections that had taken place after 1988? Catchy slogans and touchy rhetoric have taken us far from the harsh realities of life. My lone voice is unheard of, ignored and at times laughed at but I still wish to infuse some sanity in minds of masses.

    I take this gentleman either too green and naïve to have devised a comprehensive and clear plan to tackle the predicaments the nation is going through or too shrewd not to disclose his factual agenda publicly. My observations are:-

    • During the past few weeks he has completely changed his stance on many major National and International issues. He has mellowed down considerably in criticism of the USA, Drone-attacks, MQM, Pervez Musharraf and a few others. He is trying to instill in minds that only the present parliament is responsible for all evils.

    • He has teamed up with the same old lot of “Lotas” and submitting excuses to public for their inclusion in PTI. Some of them do enjoy vetter reputation amongst the public. Nevertheless, I totally refuse to believe that they have joined hands with him and have been spending huge amounts of money on his campaign only for the well-being of public.

    • He has more financial resources to expend on political activities than Zardari, Nawaz Shareef, Altaf Hussain, Chaudhry Cousins and others. Recovery of the huge amounts spent by him and his mates will be made only when he is in the Government. Very stupid will ask from who?

    I do not have blind faith in him because I can very well visualize what is ahead. Please mark my words he is worst of all. Z.A. Bhutto & Sh. Mujeeb had a carefully devised manifesto and both went by the book. It was a different ball-game that their newly-found mates misguided them. Imran Khan has no clear plan as to what he would do. He is just reciting the rhetoric like a tamed parrot that he would end corruption. How could he end corruption by spending thousands of millions of black-money on his campaign? Yes, the time is too short because people are again doing the same mistake. Change will never come if you blow the same trumpet louder. This time it is not only painfully disturbing but also lacks melody. Inclusion of pop music in rallies to add tunes is an insult to injury, by the way.

  • Kamran Fazal

    I really dont understand how some of you people claim to be neutral either you are jealous like hell on what IK has achieved single handily or you are working on the pay roll of some one else. I get pissed off when I listen or read absolutely BIASED crap coming from only some individuals like yourself. And believe me because of articles likes yours thousands of people like me who either supported the PML(N) or PPPP have now turned to IK: Let me give my feedback to your article on point to point basis:

    1 – Inshallah by the GRACE of Almighty Allah IK will become Pakistan’s Prime Minister and you will see that from your BIASED eyes. I was in Islamabad Dharna as well as Peshawar and the guy slept on charpai with normal people around him. Now you tell me – Is it porrible any of your present role model LEADERS the likes of Zardari, Ghilani, Sharif, Wali, chuadries would dare do this? Your idol Zardari doesnt even go outside of President house let alone mingle with his followers like you. They treat you like slaves and peope like you will never come out of this mentality. You people will always critise someone with outstanding integrity, dedication and who is upright and honest.

    2 – Again compare Imrans security with that of currennt ruling class and even those politicians who are not in power and you will find out about what kind of person you truly are “BIASED”, “JEALOUS” or someone who has no bloody conscience. Your Prime Minister Ghilani when he travels anywhere he has almost 200 – 300 security cars with him and thousand of personnel. Similarly what about your other GOD Fathers like Sharif brothers. They have 2-3 thousands police men from Punjab either protecting them or their families. But yes if IK has few personal body guards its very hard for you to digest and you right blog about it. People will just laugh about you and that proves my point regarding you either having no conscience and BIASED opinion or either working on someone’s agenda.

    3 – I think you were not even born when Zulifqar Ali Bhutto started his PPP so you need to read some history books or ask your elders about what i am going to state here. When he started his party he took all sort of people from everywhere feudal lords, established businessmen and even those who served with him under Ayub Khan (Military Dictator). Similarly I think you remember how PML(N) was formed? Do you? I am sure you do….but you just want your BIASED EYES TO be shut when there is something wrong about your GOD FATHERS. But now when people join PTI thats a big problem…..but if they join either PML(N) which at present they are or PPP then everything is okay and acceptable. No matter who JOIN PTI……masses trust Imran Khan and we know he will deliver unlike your Bhuttos, Zardaries or Sharifs as they have just proven to be thugs time after time.

    Inshallah the more you guys come out with your nonsense BIASED crap the more IK will get popular inshallah. In the end remember my word people with your school of thought will be out numbered and IK will clean sweep because he represents change. People like me we believe in him and yes he is our last hope because we have tried and tested your corrupt souless GOD FATHERS who have brought Pakistan to this mess. SO if IK fails…….Pakistan will fail. And I am strong believer Pakistan will not fail and inshallah the masses will bring the change in shape of IK. God bless him.

    Kamran

  • Tahir Idrees

    Point 1: IK wanted to address full-house. At 1PM there were less that 100,000 people, and at 5PM, more than 250,000. So who’s fault is that, one persons’ or 150,000 persons’?
    Point 2: You know how insecure Karachi is and what happened to BB. Now a common person wants to travel in bullet proof car in Karachi.
    Point 3: During jalsa, they did Fatiha khwani for Quaid-e-Azam on mic. You perhaps skipped it or you were not there at Jalsa.
    Point 4: Your point is somewhat valid however, people are still joining and we don’t know what final leadership will look like. Just know that IK has to use politicians against politicians but its all about top leadership that will make the difference. Youth should step up and prove to IK that we can be better politicians, how else IK would know???
    Point 5: 80million is contributed happily by patriotic nation. Unlike Zardari who distributed govt.’s money to bring people to his speech.
    Point 6: It was very intelligent move by IK not to confront MQM. I don’t have to explain reasons.
    Point 7: Every leader talked about real problems in Pakistan and showed their positive intent. It was indeed better than blame game PPP PMLN and other parties have been playing for years and eating the country in the process.
    May Allah Bless our Pakistan

  • JZ

    nice work

  • Khan.m.s.

    You have hit where it matters most but who will pay any heed to your comments

  • Uzair277

    Excellent! Haris

  • Hasan Amar

    @haris tohed i aree wd u

  • Umer Dar

    I am a big fan of Imran Khan, at one stage I was thinking of supporting him in elections by polling my vote for him. But recently I, a lot of friends of mine and family members have changed their minds. Following are the reasons you can take them as questions. If any of IK’s supporter or PTI member can answer these questions logically I will be thankful and think about my decision.

    1- Imran Khan in his book (recently published) mentioned that he helped his brother in law (in UK) in gambling and asked him to give a percentage of the winning amount to IK so he can get rid of his party’s(PTI) debts. My question is if a person can not pay off his party’s debts (10 thousand times less than the country’s debts) without gambling, how will he pay off the country’s debts? Is gambling allowed in Islam?

    2- IK cam to UK, he came in the town where I live and in the speech he said that MQM is a terrorist organisation and Altaf Hussain had killed 238 innocent people. He assured the audience that He has filed a case against Altaf Hussain and MQM in Scotland Yard with all proofs, requesting them to cancel Altaf Hussain’s nationality and declare them terrorist. But this case was never filed and he lied to the people. Imran Khan repeatedly expressed his views on the national media about MQM and Altaf Hussain, saying that they are terrorists and killers. But recently he has changed his point of view and has started say that they are revolutionary and progressive party (Because Establishment told him to say this, as both are supported by Establishment). My question here is was Imran Khan wrong at that time when he called them terrorist or he is wrong now when he is saying that they are revolutionary and progressive party? He should actually apologise to MQM what he has been saying about them before.

    3- In his speech at Karachi IK said that he will make Pakistan a real Progressive Islamic social state. My question here is what is his concept about Islamic state. When a dance party was going on the stage during all his speech, before and after. Songs were played for hours. He was confused about the dress code of a muslim woman.

    4- In a recent TV programme Imran khan refused to disclose the names of the sponsors for his party’s programmes. He said that some one gave 2.5 million rupees for Lahore but I can’t disclose his name. Sources said that 5.3 million rupees were spent only for telephonic and sms campaign about Karachi gathering. My question here is if the money is not coming from Establishment or corrupt people/black money why can’t he disclose the names of the people who are sponsoring the party? What are their interests in the party or with Imran Khan, Why are they spending so much money on the political campaign? I can understand people donating money for hospital or charitable work but for political campaign?

    5- He has been criticising the politicians changing parties, Politicians in other parties (Khursheed Mahmood Kasuri, Shah Mahmood Qureshi, Ghulam Sarwar Khan, Awais Laghari, Jamal Laghari,) How come they have become so pious, honest, noble, respectable, trustworty,inteligent and capable of running the country just by coming in Khan’s party.

    6- Where are all those new faces gone, Imran told us thousand times in last few years he will bring new faces? I would love to poll my vote to a well educated, intelligent, honest progressive young man, even though he is not famous or popular than polling my vote to a traditional politician, who has changed his party 5 times in last 15 years, Supported martial law and people like Musharaf, filthy rich and corrupt.

    7- Imran khan recently said that all those who are joining his party will follow his party’s manifesto and He will lead the revolution not them. My question here is that means what will happen when they (corrupt traditional politicians) will become majority in the party. Either there will be Imran’s dictatorship in the party or these corrupt politicians will run the party according to their wishes? If you look at IK’s parties big names they all are traditional politicians and symbol of status co.

    8- In his speech at Karachi he said that when he will come in power there will be one educational system in the country and that will be supportive of poor people and his all policies will be for poor people and middle class. My question here is how can you do that when you have Khursheed Mahmood Kasuri in your party who is running the Country’s most expensive school (Beacon House). Where 6 years old child’s parent pay Rs. 8000/- per month as tuition fee which is more than a poor man’s whole months wages? You have Laghari’s in your party who are perfect example of Feudalism and represent the elite class of the country. You have Ghulam Sarwar Khan, Hoti and swati in your party; we all know that all these people are real opportunist.

    9- I know Nawaz Sharif, Zardari, Altaf and most of the other politicians are all corrupt and dangerous for the country but the question here as why is IK only accusing Nawaz Sharif every where (Because currently he is anti Establishment). I believe that Zardari and Altaf are 100 times more dangerous for the safety, security, stability, peace and development of Pakistan but why he is only cursing Nawaz Sharif every where.

    A person who is an established killer (altaf) is a progressive revolutionary leader in Imran Khan’s view, can anybody justify this?
    A person who is an established most corrupt man of the country (Zardari) Khan never talks about him, He never talks about the corruption of Gillani and his family, He never talks about Rehman Malik (We all know him very well), He never talks about fake degree holder Babar Awan. Can you justify this?

    10- In last 15 years Imran has talked about bringing change in the country a lot. But according to my best of knowledge he has never presented any model of change he want to bring in the country, how will he bring the change, what that change will be. I mean he has always pointed towards the problem (which we all do) but he has never came out with a solutions. I have some videos of Khan where he was asked for solutions and he was clueless what to say. What kind of economic reforms his party will bring, what kind of tax reforms they will bring in, what kind of changes in the social system we will see, what is their vision about the country in 2020, Do they have any solid plan of doing this or they will work on it when they will come in power. As he talks about justice a lot, what kind of changes they will bring in the legal system to provide easy and cheap justice to every one? He was asked few times this question in last couple of years but he did not had a solid answer or solutions.
    Why Khan and his party did not came out with a solid plan and solutions (if they had one) of the today’s problems and helped the government or people to get rid of these problems. Will they only disclose the plan and solutions when they will come in power?
    I have hears a number of any lists saying that they are not aware of Imran’s stance about some of country’s most important issue?

    Whatever I have written above is what I thought about Imran and his party. I see Imran’s popularity and younger generation’s support for Imran as a very good sign for the country but these are my concerns. I would love to read or hear logical answers or comments from someone.

    Thanks

    • Usama Ahmed

      I totally agree with you. All of them are poisonous and we have to pick a lesser from them.

  • Qyousuf

    I got a million reasons to hating your article—GROW UP and GET EDUCATED!!!

  • hope2011

    Dude haris tauheed it is not first time i am reading your ANTI PTI article .. i can see you are young , greedy about rest of ur career but dude have some code of ethics and refrain from YELLOW PAGE JOURNALISM man … Be fair and unbais

  • syed zohair ail

    great article. the truth is when you will gather lota hawks around you one day they will begin to yield more influence on you and you will bound to make decisions they want you to make. Imran is losing his credibility by gathering these lotas with him. further more the ground in which PTI held its jalsa has a maximum capacity of 200,000 if no chairs are kept otherwise maximum 100,000 so please spare the rhetoric that it was attended by lakhoo or millions. how do i know this ? because i live across the street from this place and in my childhood days played numerous cricket matches there. Syed Zohair Ali

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1316610679 Ali Taj

    -Well Nothing New In Your Essay just like comments of copied from fearful incumbent politicians.

    But, few confusions need to be made clear:
    Regarding spending on Jalsa: Can you monetize the passion of 200K people from diverse background sitting on one ground, showing immense sense of solidarity, brotherhood, and mutual respect? Let suppose, because of this event there prevails a sense of oneness among people belonging to different category and as a result we can see lower rate violence in the city, lower causalities. Even, if one life gets saved from the mutual respect and regard shown and create by this unity jalsa would over ride the cost you mentioned above.

    And, my answer to your lota point is that, Imran has understand the game of politics & rules of politics in Pakistan, these rules cant be change without first getting the necessary power to alter them. So, here, I see the this tactic, he needs as I believe to play same, on same set of rules, with same umpires and but win it at any cost, he can not afford to loose it,. Once, he and his team get in then He will change the set norms, rules and practices of power politics. Why we should he will change the rules when other rely on them to continue to stay in power or to capture power? the simple answer is that Imran is a honest, sincere and loyal in his commitments, and that is what which makes him different from other Leaders. Although, his team might more or less consists of same players, but himself at top as captain will make the difference. And, final argument to believe it, is that he has not any personal interest to protect while sitting in power, his past is crystal clear, he is the person who has already spent much of his personal wealth in SKH and University serving thousands of poor families. Simple example is that only a clean man can bring a culprit into justice, not a culprit. A culprit will always protect other culprit, because it is in his best interest. So, understand these simple points.

    Regarding MQM, his target is clear, One he gets done with the major disease, the smaller ones will automatically get fixed and also, MQM now wants to be national party and thats what the must do. Previously, he wasted lots of energy focusing on these smaller target, and the bigger ones were quite happier with that, Thanks God Now he has understood that prob lies at top.

  • Anonymous

    Has the author of this retarded article never seen Obama’s security motorcade ?
    And they where by gun toting youth they were police officers

    Of pti supporters dont mind waiting for imran Kahn why do u ? He was preparing his speech u pmln agent

  • Mr.

    Its done the next prime minister of pakistan is Altaf Hussain. Jiye altafa!

  • Anonymous

    Security ? Was normal police which u get in USA as well

  • Anonymous

    Private jets trips do not cost 10s of thousands only 2,000 max and policts is about rhetoric , policy is for later

  • BILAL KHAN

    1. “A man in his 50’s inducting men in their late 70’s hoping to represent the youth seems ludicrous” – THAT SHOWS YOUR SO IMMATURE IN YOUR VIEWS!
    HELLO! PTI IS TO RULE AND LEAD “”THE WHOLE OF PAKISTAN”" AND NOT JUST PAKISTAN’S YOUTH AND FORGET THE REST! SO I DON’T GET WHY IF IK INDUCTS MEN IN THEIR LATE 70′S SEEMS LUDICUROUS TO YOU??

    2. IK ‘WILL’ MAKE PAKISTAN INTO COUNTRIES LIKE SINGAPORE, MALAYSIA, TURKEY ETC. PAKISTAN “”CURRENTLY IS NOT”" LIKE THOSE COUNTRIES SO YOU NEED BODYGUARDS WITH GUNS TO PROTECT YOU FROM ANYTHING UNEXPECTED!

    FIREPOWER BY YOUNG MEN IN THEIR 20′S AND 30′S WAS SURPRISING TO YOU?? HELLO! 18+ OR IS IT 21+, IS “”LEGALLY”" ALLOWED TO CARRY FIREPOWER.

    YOU ARE JUST JELOUS OF IMRAN KHAN’S PAKISTAN TEHREEK-E-INSAAF’S MASSIVE SUCCESS AND POPULARITY!

  • Arrowminds

    Dear Haris,
    Try to be optimistic rather than pessimistic because I’ve perceived your thoughts about PTI or IK as like glass is half empty. How can you think like this way for IK because he has successfully delivered projects like hospital,university and worldcup.
    For an instance if I backup your comments it means I myself want to give one more chance to other parties to make this country more worse-no way. Ohh, your blog recommends I should not vote for IK because
    -Older reputed guys are in his party
    Answer: Will you cast vote for a known or unknown person in your local area?

    I think Haris you are living in a world of fool paradise because you dont know what other politicians are doing.

    -Weapon display in jalsa
    Answer-I think you are not aware that all other politicians are also having security . Even celebrities, rich person are having security due to some reason and I think IK have got a valid reason for this secirity.

  • Somiraja

    He is at least better than Mr 10 %, certainly pays more tax than Rs 5000, his son has not taken 9 million rupees car and certainly had the curtsy to pay for his jalsa.

    • Horizan

      We all dont Know when and from where Nawaz Sharif has paid 5000 Tax.? in 2007 when he waws not in coutnry and the Tax amont has been paid on an amount of share profits! Why we have started balm game Fact is fact. no doubt IK is better leader but it doesnt mean that we start defending his shortcomings and start blaming its opponent and critcis ! Have pateint to bear constructive criticism.

  • Ahmad

    dude.. realization is not ‘helped’ by anything.. it just comes.. you just realize. Wrong language again.. just say ‘I realized’..

    • Pakistani.

      People like you are the bad seed. Stop pointing other people. If you think you are highly educated then please use it for pakistan future not correcting other peoples English mistakes. grow up.

  • Ahmad

    Also, IK is trying. EVERYBODY else in Pak does what you just stated. Sure, he has the same shortcomings, but he has good qualities as well, which the others lack. Even if his policies are a bit vague we should give him a chance.

  • Pakistani

    There are two extremes here,
    a) on one side IK believes in system regularization, self-respect and respect of his nation (here nation does not mean Pakistani only rather his cricket team at world cup, his campanion at Shuakat Khanum Hospital, his party supporter at PTI and may be us at PM position).
    b) on the other side, his aggression which could lead Pakistan to isolation in certain situations. A diplomatic person is the requirement of time, may be like Musharraf.

    All of us know, everybody will make money if he gets the chance. In normal course of life, we do as well. But here we need a person who thinks for Pakistan first and than ……… whatever.

    Regret to say here, IK calls for Sindhi, Punjabi, Pathan, Balochi… Mianwalians, but not a single PAKISTANI !!

    Apparently, his thoughts and intentions are good for Pakistan if implemented. We have tested almost all of major parties and seen the outcomes. This time we should give a chance to him. I believe he could not demage Pakistan as it was damaged since 1980s.

  • Saeedansari_216

    I agree with 200%

  • Muneeruddinkhan

    i wish if you cld have asked all these Questions or showed your concern at the earlier times when we had PML n PPP only we wld not have been at this stage now ….. i dont know why every one is pointing or doing criticism (so called positive) on IK why not they criticise PML-N PPPP ANP MQM(Any one will dare?) ANP … why only imran khan?? Chairs incident took place in Kasur jalsa every one highlighted the next day same event happened in PML-N jalsa but no one highlighted??? Why no one is criticising others Jalsa from where they geting funds? when PML-N induct same Q league Members no one criticise them but when PTI induce them then PTI is wrong ….. What is this???? r u all being payed by PML-N?? do we have the right to Criticise your postings/Blogs (Positive one :) )??? Can we?i assume u all are payed?

  • nauman

    I disagree with the figure of 80 million it is at least around 400million to 500 million spent on the concert/picnic outing/so called jalsa . Imran khan promise to make an ideal Pakistan, every politician has the same speech before the elections nothing is new in it. None of the politician said that he will increase the corruption, destroy the economy, and spread the anarchy. Can he give at least one policy that how he will bring the change??? Can anyone ask him explain the labor policy, Police reform Policy or any another policy and its implication. To my view till now he has no policy, he is busy in collecting the spent cartridges.

    nauman

    • Pakistani

      shut the fuck up dude…we need change in the country and educated Ruler. he is spending his own money and not taking it from you. Keep your policies to your self, this country need change and your backward mind still wanna bring those dirty assholes back in Government. so grow up and accept the change.

  • Abdul Rehman

    Tum log kabhi nahee sudhro ga…you should be deposited in a Psychiatric Facility..

  • Mirza Ms

    I am indeed disheartened by reading these lines.. not for that they carry criticism, but for the realization that they are FACTS. Everything about IK since this July is a disappointment. It reminds me of his statement at the 92’ world cup handing over ceremony “….I have won the world cup”. All others which worked their skins off and pulled miracles were sent water-fetching while the SKIPPER took the credit alone. That’s exactly what happened. All those who toiled their lives for the last 15 years were lost somewhere in the crowd with tears in their eyes and saw their one-man-army (so-called) having a pride smile by winning garbage of both the main stream political parties of Pakistan. In my personal gatherings I shared this fear earlier as well that “immaturity of a human being, mixed with false sense of his bravery (self-claimed), only causes an exuberance which burns one’s own house.. [ghar ko aag lag gai ghar ke charagh se..]. We still have some time to go to the polls.. I hope IK reviews his way forward.

  • Humanityfriend

    Aoa, Imran speeches was based on facts and figures, it reminded me one of the intellectual speech made by president Obama in Greebay Wisconsin on health reforms issues. Yes Harris there is always rooms for improvement. I take some of your points valid and justified but other points has no meaning at all. Imran is much different than other traditional politicians who are myopic and don’t get out of their self. Imran has practically done many charitable work and he he is the first person who talked about rule of Khilafith-Rashida, the role model regime for eternity. we pray that Allah help him and all those who come with sincere intentions to serve the nation. Amin

  • M.Saeed

    Haris, you are passive supporter of Imran. This is your fourth anti-Imran tirade and each one gets higher than earlier comments in response against your outbursts. Is it not an evidence of increasing public support to Imran high-lighted through your effort here? In any case, you are raising Imran higher by blowing negative wind.

  • Anonymous

    Apropos thoughts Haris !!!

    It seems to me for a last few years that it has become fashionable/trendy to support PTI. If you question IK and his vague policies, you are outright/blindly deemed backwards. I for one surely think that he is not the last hope for Pakistan but perhaps deservers a chance. He sounds lunatic when he states Altaf Hussain has killed 200+ odd people himself but is quick to defend Azam Sawati about his cases with ‘innocent until proven guilty’ card. By no means am I a MQM fan but he does not seem to excercise balanced judgment in this regard. He needs to mature up.

  • Ahsan Malik

    Hitting below the belt & petty criticism. I actually enjoyed reading this because thats all this piece of writing provides, ENJOYMENT.

  • ahooo

    This article is a bunch of BS….. get some life dude…

  • Horizan

    The total budget ok Shukat Khanam Hospital is 3000 Million/per year. As per PTI they ve spend 600 Million for Karachi Jalsa and 734 Million for Lahore Jalsa! What a waste of money from a leader of Poor Country. No Doubt Ik is best leader but we should accept the reality which is bitter here. He should not adopt the conventional modes of politics by spending mch money and indcuting corroupt politicians. There were a number of people in Jalsa who were protesting for Affia and there was aperson(Khursheed Qasori EX-Fedreal Ministor) on stage who had handed over Affia to America.

    • Saady

      600 million and 734 million, do you know how many 0′s come in these figures? 10 mil, 20 mil or even 30 mil max still its more then enough. Use your brains please.

    • umer

      people like you are in between us and change

  • Zorrokingdom

    u r biased

  • Phaty_purani_jeans

    U r one of dose SOBs who jst knw how to bark at goood things…Damn cant u seee practicle examples infront of u..?????

  • http://www.facebook.com/khizer.farooq Khizer Hayat Farooq

    @Haris Tohid….So let me answer you from the very start

    1. You say..the Jalsa time was 1 and IK showed up 4 hours later…was he waiting for enough crowd to gather and all…??
    Ans: If your so-called PRIME MINISTER, GOVERNOR, CHIEF MINISTER, HOME MINISTER, etc…would have paid tributes at the Quaid Mazar on time instead of visiting the Mazaar at the Jalsa time and IK had to wait for security clearance from the Home Department to visit the Jalsa Gah itself, HE WOULD HAVE SURELY BEEN ON TIME….

    2. You talk about the body guards and all….
    Ans: Whereas I totally agree with you on this stance on the number of body guards he had but let us take things the other way…what if he was attacked by some party men who have grudges with him and burnt his posters in protest when he visited LONDON to lodge a complain…The whole jalsa as well as the ppl from the crowd would have suffered various injuries…TRY TO THINK THIS WAY…

    3. Paying tribute to QUAID-E-AZAM….
    Ans: Listen to his speech again dear….as well as the party members…who promised the Jinnah on making this country a blessed place..

    4. On the LOTA force and the man in 70′s….
    Ans: This is surely no LOTA FORCE…Ppl are called LOTA’s when they change parties in favor of good posts being offered in the government formation…IK has nothing for now…he is not in the government…and neither is he offering a Seat for Minister (HOW CAN HE FOR NOW)? The man you are talking about in the 70′s is MR. HASHMI…try to read his history and his sacrifices for the country as well as for PML(N)…he is one of the most respectable politician in the country, who is not after money but for betterment..23 years for Pakistan…Senior most politician…Most of the ppl attending the Jalsa when questioned by me…they were there for JAWED HASHMI…as they respect him alot….

    5. Spending 80 million rupees….
    Ans: Whereas I have no idea on the exact amount spent on the Jalsa…I would say…surely spending was done…Try to look it this way…80 million or 8 million…the money was there own..and not taxpayers or extortion money which you see on almost all other Jalsa’s. More of BB’s banners for 27 Dec were hanging on every signboard rather the PAID PTI boards and banners….

    6. PTI and MQM….
    Ans: Are you aware of this???? If YES, then I think you should Join the Intelligence….

    7. IK SPEECH…
    Ans: The Karachi Jalsa was mainly focused on the ppl who had joined PTI…Those speeches were mentioned almost everything…IK was only left for Karachi to be thanked…Now if he would have repeated all the things already said..Today you would have wrote…IK REPEATED EVERYTHING WHAT OTHERS SAID…

    P.S I don’t have any party affiliation. I am just a voice. Whereas i dearly support IK to bring a change to PAKISTAN. We have tested and seen everyone on every platform….MY VOTE IS FOR IK….

    • Sarmad Khan

      good comment

    • umer

      100% agreed with your every alphabet…

  • Mobeen

    Dear Haris, i have been reading your articles i dont know why. Seriously what is wrong with you??? do you do any sort of homework or research before writing?? Whats so wrong in giving chance to a new party? dont you see the plight of our country? are you that ignorant? why dont you criticize others??

    The security was provided by sindh government as it is their duty…

    Grow up please.

    your narrow thinking will lead you nowhere

    • momin

      hey guts u r mistaken its not the new party , only new is Imran Khan rest u know me know every pakistani know who the hell are with him.
      May Allah bless this LOTA party

  • Khadija

    Nice beta!

  • Shahbazbutt

    any way we love Imran Khan,
    We have very bad habit to criticise

  • M Shaih Gic

    Let the educated, patriotic, wise, respectful, progressive, contemporary, uncorrupted, benevolent individual lead the nation.
    Nominees are: (1) Asif Zardari (2) Nawaz Sharif (3) Shabaz Sharif (4) Imran Khan (5) ALtaf Hussain.
    Whose resume shows out to be the best? hands down, (4) IMRAN KHAN!!!… Please stop the criticism and start using your brain and prayers, to help the man succeed!!!

    • Cryptic

      Prayers he will definitely need!!!

      Would you vote for a PTI without Imran Khan??? If not, then this is a “personal cult following he has rather than a political following.”

      • umer

        you think there was any Pakistan without Jinnah??
        PML ever had the reputation or backing without Jinnah?
        Hum mulk bachane nikle han ayo hamare sath chalo….
        and we will pray and we are praying

  • naqi

    The above article is rubbish. For instance article says IK did not mention Karachi problems, less talk on how to do etc. Let me say IK already mentioned number of times ” peace in Karachi’ and that should answered. Secondly, this time he less criticise and gave more agenda. However, to be more specific on agenda dont need to talk in open mass rally. This kind of debate should be made on media in front of analysists. There other points in the article which are baseless.

  • Sumair Azam

    What ever u wrote above clearly shows the writer is living in a world where unicorn dance around on rainbows… HELLO reality check IK is in Pakistan and Rome was not built in a day… Remember one thing some ILLs of the society can only be curbed with time through regular dosage of corrective remedies…………….. Pardon me for bringing this up but Alcohol was HARAM-ed years after the advent of Islam…. Slavery was not advocated by Islam but Prophet PBUH never banned it……. Some things needs to be slowly inducted … All ILLs cannot be fixed by an EXPECTO PETRONUM the writer seems a avid believer of …….. One thing at a time…. it took 13 years for the Prophet PBUH to build an Islamic Welfare state… Y expect miracles from a mere mortal with no divine interventions……. I rest my case

  • Taimoor Khawar

    Nothing is perfect in this world..but intensions and behavior makes the difference..Above all IK is much much better than others..we have voted and gave chance to all others..so why shouldn’t give to our last hope..so please stop critisizing him on these little things as these are the part of our politics..

  • Cheema Usman

    I will answer your 7 questions.
    Ist Imran Khan did not come late on purpose. He had to go through alot of traffic like normal person does on busy road. And obviusly he was never gona be the first one to come on stage that would be idiotic.
    2nd imran donot have personal bodyguards but i think he should have. But way scurity is important , pakistan need imran and pakistani’s need imran and there are bad out there.
    3rd imran is only Ist man ever talk about social welfare state. No one ever talk about it. everybody talk about quaid’s pakistan and institutions issue. But no one dream of pakistan as welfare state like scadavavian contries like imran. No one have idea how to do it except imran.
    4th imran is taking people as people bring vote , vote help win and win will make sure change will come. Once in PM seat if some one will be corrupt, imran will through them out. I can ensure you that much.
    5th its not corruption money people paid for its with Love and respect for pakistan change and imran khan good cause.
    6th MQM is not our target. PML and PPP are real enemy of country lets kill the daddy’s , kiddies like mqm will have no one to back them up. so they will finish automatically.
    7th what new imran can say. The problems are same as they were 10 years ago. these are main problems, fix them and all be fixed automatically.
    Finish corruption , tax collection, railways , PIA, Steel mill, wapda, inflation.
    Good Luck Imran.
    Usman Cheema
    Wazirabad.

  • Ali_asad425

    Do not worry folks, criticism is better to be percieved as a motivating and energizing factor.So do not take it as criticism rather take it as an a motivating factor.My humble request to all PTIANS that they should focus on their destination. Keep going IK, AND PTI.

  • Cheema Usman

    I will answer your 7 questions.
    Ist Imran Khan did not come late on purpose. He had to go through alot of traffic like normal person does on busy road. And obviusly he was never gona be the first one to come on stage that would be idiotic.
    2nd imran donot have personal bodyguards but i think he should have. But way scurity is important , pakistan need imran and pakistani’s need imran and there are bad out there.
    3rd imran is only Ist man ever talk about social welfare state. No one ever talk about it. everybody talk about quaid’s pakistan and institutions issue. But no one dream of pakistan as welfare state like scadavavian contries like imran. No one have idea how to do it except imran.
    4th imran is taking people as people bring vote , vote help win and win will make sure change will come. Once in PM seat if some one will be corrupt, imran will through them out. I can ensure you that much.
    5th its not corruption money people paid for its with Love and respect for pakistan change and imran khan good cause.
    6th MQM is not our target. PML and PPP are real enemy of country lets kill the daddy’s , kiddies like mqm will have no one to back them up. so they will finish automatically.
    7th what new imran can say. The problems are same as they were 10 years ago. these are main problems, fix them and all be fixed automatically.
    Finish corruption , tax collection, railways , PIA, Steel mill, wapda, inflation.
    Good Luck Imran.
    Usman Cheema
    Wazirabad.

    • Hamid_sohail78

      I think there is not a much difference then between PTI and other political parties, 3 years back he was banned by MQM for entring into Karachi. so that means you have deal with MQM then

  • Bilalzeb09

    Is anyone on this planet perfect?
    Imran Khan is as much of a human being as we are! We dont expect him to be perfect, and neither he can! His intentions are good and that is what matters. We all want a change and expect a change but please bear in mind that this cannot be done overnight! What do u expect Imran khan to be? He is not perfect as only Allah(SWT) is perfect!
    so please dont come up with lame arguments.

  • faisal

    love u IK …. our votes for u

  • Haris Maqsood

    Good article. I agree.

  • chand

    Dear Author Haris, i must say you didnt prepare well for this article :) You looks childish in your writing, specially first two points were big bongi by you :) you wasn’t him to be assassinated like Benazir?? huh. get a life. and who ever paid you to write this cheap article, please pay back with damages. lolz

    • Hamid_sohail78

      my dear friend we should have courage to face the criticism. he is quite right in few of things, its not the change to bring old used peoples who always switched their gears according to situations. just tell me he is fighting for last fifteen years and all those peoples who deserved to be with him in this time; they are not even in pictures now. where is umar cheema !!!! Like other parties all new and heavy weights have hijacked PTI. For last five years I am PTI worker but believe me the party is totally slipped from its orginal agenda. We are really collecting the garbage of musharaf league, except Javed Hashmi no one is right induction in this party. Shah Mehmood has joined PTI just because he couldn’t got foreign ministry and left PPP.

      Best Wishes for only Imran Khan :)

      • Falak Sher

        Being a Pakistani Citizen, i am convinced that we should not put Pakistan in the hands of an inexperienced and emotional persons. After 12 October 1999, many efforts have been made to bring a person who could run the country smoothly.. Gen Pervaiz Musharif for almost 9 years, Mr Zafar Ullah Jamali, Ch Shujat Hussain, Mr Shaukat Aziz and Syed Yousaf Raza Gillani… None has been able to keep the Pakistan on right track. Nawaz Sharif was given only 2 years almost….and during these tenures he has made a few achievements upon which Pakistani feel a proud of being Pakistani. Like declaration of Nuclear Country, Motorway, Gawadar port. Costal Highway, JF Thunder 17, concept of privatization, denial of foreign aid, Peeli Taxi, promotion of industry (establishing stat/industrial areas free of tax for few years) etc, etc…all this was done in a very short time i.e.almost 2 years in both govts. But Musharaf had a lot of time but could not deliver.
        If i ask the question what were the major achievements of Musharaf in such a long tenure…..will u be able to count upto to 4….?
        achievements of PPP Govt…..
        Achievements of PML (Q) Govt
        Achievements of MMA Govt in KPK (NWFP)……
        Achievements of present Chief Ministers…….. in Punjab, Sindh, Balochistan and KPK …
        keeping aside the emotions…….think with cool mind and decide…….please dont put Pakistan in the hands of inexperienced persons once again…decide in the favour of Pakistan.

    • ash

      dear moon, I cant find anything childish in this article, infact u r being childish who cannot accept any criticism on IK. IK is the one who was always shouting ” bhai? what bhai? altaf is ghunda… and im wondering why he didnt say a word. if u r afraid of his assassination then ask IK to sit home.

  • 1sikander Ali

    Omer Cheema was right behind IK the whole time, Arif Alvi was with IK throughout the preparation of the whole event and on the Jalsa. I think you were also Unable to spot Naeem-ul-Haq, Fozia Qusoori and Andleeb who were with him throughout from preparation to execution.. petty mind pointing out petty issues..

    MQM could not stop PTI after what happened in Lahore. Punjab Gov was unable to stop them at any place because if that was done it would hail all sorts of sympathy for PTI to the bitter disadvantage of PMLN PPP and MQM. Similarly, MQM trying to stop IK would be detrimental for MQM.

    Rally is a public procession and it only starts once enough people have gathered.

    You object IK’s security(4 armed men).. write someday about the 100 vehicle convoy of Mr. Prime Minister.

    I donate to SKMH, IKF and PTI and I am happy to do so and will continue because i know my money is being spent where it is supposed to be.

    Jahangeer Tarren (according to a 2010 report from Ansar Abaasi who is the most trusted investigative journalist in Pakistan) is the only Politician who has declared assets completely including his hard earned business empire and even paid taxes on agricultural income. Plus he went above and beyond and declared Millions in taxes paid on earnings by him and his family (these are not customer auto-deducted sales taxes so fervently waved around by Hanif Abasi regarding Shreef brothers in an attempt to fool the nation). Kindly stop hating on people just because they are rich and became so by there own entrepreneurship and hard work and they pay taxes.

    IK, the only man who makes and effort to chalk out the plan for future Pakistan in his meeting with people. Talks about Local Gov’s control on primary and intermediate Education and local courts to solve cases at a more decentralized level, tax collection, relation between GDP and tax ratios, relation between investment and corruption and how he is going to increase one by bringing the other down. Not enough, maybe you want him to read policy papers instead? Never heard Nawaz or Zardari go beyond Musharaf bashing and mudslinging each other.

    Haters gona hate.. May Allah help IK
    Ameen

  • Hafeez_hafeez39

    positive criticism is right of any intalectual. No doubt IMRAN KHAN is making a team of elder and experienced politicians. It is just to guide the youngsters and traind them in the sonamy of politics.I think seven objections are really childish and not according to ground realities.

  • Reason1978

    very good Harris..i agree.. people like kasuri and asif ahmad ali cannot bring the change in pakistan.

  • umer

    First of all your point 2) dude u ever saw a General moving on Islamabad Highway??once the guard hit my car side mirror to stop and make way for 3 star General…and Imran Khan has 4 body guard then whats BAD???its KARACHI…I am in Canada for last 2 year and i never saw even a pistol in hands of police…its always there somewhere in belt…But i guess with current situation that was a must…
    for point 4) How many MPAs MNAs are there in assembly which are in 30s….dude “DO IN ROME AS THE ROMANS DO”……Do you know the average age of US 110 Congress man….any idea???
    Its 57 for representatives and 51 for senate and i guess they run the US in best possible way….
    and btw its is not constructive criticism as most of the issued you raised were petty in a country facing bigger issues relating to its sovereignty….
    You have a habit of seeing the glass half empty…..This is surely the last time i wasted my time in reading Haris Tohid article…

  • SRB

    Very Well written article…..

  • S_amina_hassan

    Well written .IK needs to answer these if he wants to retain his vote bank.

  • DKAIMKHANI

    so someone said in the comments MQM is not PTI’s target then what the hell were they doing in Karachi was their target ANP in sohrab goth area or PPP in lyari? it makes no sense IK is not the man of his words first he claims MQM was behind 12th May and now apparently he has forgiven mqm why did he not say a single word about MQM in Karachi i have been saying from Day 1 if Imran Khan wants to make a government he will have to visit NINE ZERO to get MQM’s ashirwad thats the reason why he is silent about MQM . What happend to IK’s strict principle about MQM he forgot all about his so called “karkuns” that were “aparently” killed on 12 may what a shame IK . I mean think about it yourself Imran khan does a fabulous Jalsa i totally agree in Karachi and does not say a word abt MQM? who he hates so much calls them murderers extortionists IK can make no difference in Karachi’s politics he will mayb get 2-3 seats the ones ANP has other than that good luck to IK and he is not the only hope. TO THE PEOPLE WHO SAY LETS TRY IMRAN OUT LISTEN THIS IS NOT A CRICKET MATCH THAT WE CAN TRY OUT A NEW PLAYER THIS IS ABOUT RUNNING A GOVERNMENT WHO 19 CRORE PPL DEPEND ON U CANT RISK THE FATE OF PPL BY JUST GIVING A CHANCE TO SOMEONE WHO HAS NO PRINCIPLES WHO CAN PLAY POLITICS ON HIS PPLS DEAD BODIES (12 MAY) AND THEN IGNORES EVERYTHING LIKE NOTHING HAPPEND THE REASON WHY I CRITIZE IK IS BECAUSE PPL THAT IMRAN KHAN IS DIFFERENT HE IS NOT DIFFERENT HE IS JUST LIKE THE CURRENT POLITICIANS WE CURRENTLY HAVE HIRING LOTAS PLAYING POLITICS ON DEAD BODIES

  • Pakistan Khan

    The cat will be out of bag soon. The riding on the shoulders of agencies will not remain hidden from the eyes of common folks, let alone, serious unbiased analysts and historians. Revolutions can never be brought by the turncoats.
    One word for the supporters and well-wishers of IK. Those who criticize IK, do not do so for any ill will or personal grudges. They do in same spirit as IK does to all his political foes and rivals. Secondly, if blind following can ruin the revolutionary spirits of past, like that of ZAB`s PPP in 1970s and rise of MQM in 1980s, it will not do any good to IK in2010s. Whether you like it or nor, ZAB and Altaf Hussein (I am not a political supporter or beneficiary of politics of PPP nor of MQM) revolutionized more the politics of this country, in one way or other. If ZAB is credited with bringing the politics to the doorstep of common man, MQM, justifiably, is credited with sending the middle class youth to the elected houses of the country. But both of these parties have almost lost their political destinations and visions, as their affiliates have deified their political leadership and are not ready to listen to legitimate criticism of their leadership. I am afraid, the followers of IK has arrived at that point much earlier than anybody else, which is not a healthy sign neither for IK, nor his party nor this country.

    • Naseemsha

      hay i want to ask you some thing what u mean by hidden agencies tell me who iz there in agencies indians americans or brave pakistanis okk i agree with u that democracy iz much better then army or what ever bt tell me what pakistan has gained frm ths old system loot maar politicis and i must say that army iz much better then these theifs and ma advise iz to u that dont be a kid any more try to learn and understand and listen we pakistani youths iz supporting imran khan not agencies and we respect imran khan dont ever write ik

      • Falak Sher

        Has IK paid tax to Pakistan before entering into Politics..? Has he not got Plot from Govt stating that he has no plot in Punjab.. but his assets show he has a huge land/many plots before getting that plot…Has he contributed when he was member of Public Accounts Committee in national Assembly against corruption…
        Gen Musharif was not corrupt, a experienced four star general but with greedy and corrupt team in spite of having a long tenure of 9 years could not deliver. He has nothing at his credit except bloodshed in Pakistan.
        Shaukat Aziz for 3 years, Yousaf Raza Gillani 3 year nothing at his credit which is for the pakistan… except mega corruption scandal of Railway, PIA, Steel Mil, NICL, NLC, Hajj Scandal….due to non-experience
        Benazir (ruled for 4 years) having some allegations of corruption did better as compared to the present PPP Govt. Gave the gift of Missile Technology.
        Nawaz Sharif (ruled for 5 years) has done better as compared to other Govts. He has many things at his credits like Motorway, Atomic Bomb, JS 17 thunder, Gawadar Port, privatization etc…..
        Present Punjab Govt is doing better as compared to other provincial Govt. Has many credible achievements comparatively…like Aashiana housing, Danish Schools, Yellow Taxi, Work in Education Sector, encouragement of Talent/position holder students, work during dengue virus, following the merit in appointments, no corruption scandal..comparatively doing better. Because of his experience and dedications
        Should we put Pakistan again in the hands of inexperienced leader/persons.?

  • Shariqnajeeb

    Sadly, this article is written by a typical skeptic. If this article was meant to criticize PTI positively, the author wouldn’t have used words such as ‘blab’. Although I am a PTI supporter, I also found some aspects of the jalsa a bit disappointing. But the fact of the matter of is that no matter how much you whine about it, the jalsa WAS successful.

    As far as lotas are concerned, you can NOT win the elections in Pakistan without including the vote-banks of people living landlords in Sindh and Punjab. As sad as it might seem, this is one of the bitter truths people should accept. Oh and in case you have forgotten, the team which Imran lead in the ’92 World Cup was a team consisting of future alleged match-fixers (Wasim, Ijaz Ahmed, Salim Malik, Mushtaq Ahmed to name a few). They won the World Cup because they were lead by an honest leader and an honest leadership makes all the difference.

  • R Fahad Farooq

    i red just the first two points and i decided not to waste my time.Write something factual APAS KI BAATEIN are not to be written in public articles.

  • Arham

    i cant understand, what is the definiton of LOTA?? because if changing party is lota then everyperson in this country is lota. A person who was first part of one media group and now has joined other tv channel or now writes for other newspaper is a media lota by this definition. A person who was teaching in one organisation, resigns and joins other university is educational lota by this definition. for God sake, changing party after resign is not lotacracy. Actual lotacracry is in punjab assembly where forward block of PMLQ is supporting the ideology of PMLN without resigning. They are part of PMLQ and back PMLN. This is lotacracy. I cant understand, how well educated persons of media can nominate those persons as lota who are joining PTI after resigning

  • S Nasrullah

    First Shah Mahmood Qureshi from PPP and now Javed Hashmi from PML(N) have joined forces with Imran Khan’s PTI and the swelling popularity would definitely launch him to his desired goal to lead the destiny of the Country, ruined by succession of inept and corrupt Politicians and Megalomaniac military. The buoyant force of Pakistani youth joining the ranks in battalions augurs well. The youth of Pakistan is educated, enthusiastic and energetic and would surely turn around the stunted economic growth, the pervasive lawlessness and the perverse policies of the imbecile and the impotent PPP govt.
    The proof of the pudding, as is commonly acknowledged, is in the eating. We have tried and tested PPP and PML(N) in turns and they failed us. Let us try PTI and Imran. In any case successive election processes would purify our perceptions and would sharpen our sights to elect the deserving.

  • Duaamasood1991

    Strongle disagree with this article…..just see the role of IMRAN KHAN…..don’t waste time in writing & calculating the total cost of the Jslsa.

  • Fatimagillani

    very true he is just playing with the pschye of ppl. One more point that i cud not understand was people were shouting “Go Zardari Go Zardari”and he cud not stop obbessing abt Mian Sahab

  • Fatima_bk1

    A person who cant give name to his own daughter is going to change the destiny of PAKISTAN SERIOUSLY !!!! i am amazed at the naiveness of our nation.

    God save us from ourselves !!!

    • PakJam

      Do not be personal. No body claims that he is angel. However comparing to MQM’s Altaf Hussain who is sitting in UK and doing leadership of Urdu Speaking Muhajirs (I myself is one) is no good example as well. So please be careful to say such things about anybody.

    • Mumzybumzy

      Whom are you going to vote for? Ppp or pml n or maulana fazalur rahman?

  • Ibraheem

    This time vote for Imran…He defiantly have body guards specially in Karachi because the law in order situation in Karachi is really heartbreak so it is not the point to be be noted.

    ibraheemsaudi@yahoo.com

  • ABDUL BASIT

    I don’t take it as criticism for the sake of criticism but i’m very much clear that the best option available right now in our country is Imran Khan.

  • Alig7

    Let’s be hypothetical about people’s view about leadership in Pakistan, Nawaz Shareef hoarding money abroad already tried and tested, Zardari co chairman of party that is hijacked by some torment and highly corrupted leaders and Future Bilawal and Hamza Shahbaz so on and so forth. Nepotism and fudealism from many years has destroyed our country but we as nation never want to get rid of them and we still back them n cheer for them. Are we a free nation? Imran Khan is no angel but he has never being tried before snd change always come with new people and he will and he can.

  • LongLivePK

    i dint waste my time reading this article, but read last few lines and i agree with “please stop calling IK the last hope for Pakistan, believe me the world is not ending in 2012.”

    yeah, i am IK’s supporter, but calling him last hope? seriously?

    May Allah bless our country! Aameen

  • Bilal_chouhan

    very healthy criticism, with complete logical reasoning, but one i wanna add here that IK and his supporters should have some respect and ability to listen neutral and positive criticism……

  • Arshad Mehmood

    most of the supporters of pti argued that ppp and pmln are tested and they failed not pti IK should be tested. i agreed but he should be tested as a mayor or deputy moyor of any city than he should be gived chance as a PM.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mohsin-Sarah/100001960004350 Mohsin Sarah

    Imran Khan Zinda Baad .

  • Asghar

    Why we support IK is that every one else is tested. This man is still to be tested in the fields of Politics. He has been tested in two other fields, captain of Pakistan Cricket team and as a philanthropist. Luckily he passed both the tests with flying colors so the people of Pakistan are giving his another chance. I do not agree with the comment of one of the participant that he be given the seat of a mayor first. No sir! was Nawaz Sharif or Benazir or ZAB or for that matter Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Zia, Musharraf given the seats of Mayors that they ruled this country. This man has a lots of leadership qualities plus has fairly good management qualities. Lets give him a chance

    • Asghar Khan

      I seriously doubt that IK can bring change…the corruption has been spread upto grass root level in our country…every single person needs to be changed individually..every inch and bit needs to be clean. I am not saying that i dont have any hope for good but i seriously doubt that what IK is saying, will be able to do as well…and also now i dont think that “clean” people are joining him. the only clean i can see is Jawed Hashmi thats it, to the best of my knowledge….just let the senate election happen and it will be PPP sitting in the senate and it will then not be easy for any other govt to work properly, if any party other then PPP win….

  • S. Nasir Mehdi

    Siasat khel nai hondi khlarian de. Zar walay jeet tay hain ya zan waley

  • Shezishah

    a very honest and good review. We need to take the criticsim constructively and be better because that is what we claim we are. Thank you for the fine points.

  • Realist

    How can IK bring change with old corrupt horses and a with a backing from army & establishment.

  • M-alimirza

    Dear Mr.Haris………Iam really forced to say this but would definetly make you mind think in the right direction, your thoughts are like all the other status quo convetnional poiticians who try to take weeds out of things……Please man we do not want this ENOUGH………a person who has a unblemished history in terms of honesty and deliverance is trying to mend things and has started this movement since i think you were in oblivion mode. So Instead please ponder on the fact that we cannot give you a perfect individual but atleast an individual who has no political history and fedual history and wants to make thingas happen……………so support him and refrain from the conventiaonal criticism or i guess u are hell bent on doing this for oth4er objectives…………

  • shamimbhai

    atlaf bhai is the grate who is bring the change of this city packistan, atlaf bhai is own vary hoope

    • Maalsy

      shamimbhai…if you lov ur altaf bhai so much…then go educate yourself..!!

    • Pakistan Zindabad

      You’re living in cuckoo land shamimbhai. The only thing your Altaf Bhai can change is further increase in supply of arms, extortion, target killing, harrasement, and abusing people.

  • Nasir K Zong

    For your kind INformation….1-this is very low sense of humor do u have i was there Roads were Blocked every where thats y he came 4 hours laters 2-Read the history of Quaid e Azam… he is not Islamic … He was Secular type……………….. Same lyk Imran khan…… 3- do u want to kill Imran khan same lyk Benzir bhuto… Shame… 4-quaid e azam was also congress member after that he joined pml, what about him is he also lota… ??? 5- 80 million so what?? i also donate 5000 rs for his party every month.. there are many followers who funnded. 6- he is just silent for mqm bcos, Pakistan is already facing trouble & target killing.. just remember what was happend in Sulah hudebia..7- every 1 who has mindsetup very well know cruption is a biggest thing which destroyed country’s Progress.. and stay tune Policies are on the way.. his policy about energy (26feb2012) is best ever in Pakistan. increase your info plz………..

    • Chaudhryakram1

      Good answer… bt still no one is perfect.. bt we all hope Imran Khan may bring some good thisngs as all others have got their chances even twice… so it will be better to give chance to Imran Khan.. I agree with you buddy..

  • RUDY

    well this is so shamefull, y r u being so selffishh ?? u worried abut workers from past 15 years y dunt u worry abut ur country ? thousands of ppl dying, corupption and many more problems. Steps which are important to b taken is to change the governement and one more thing this is the same ppl party which all pakistans wanted to b in government but the differnece is of a leader similarly if IK is honest every one else will hve to b honest.. A fresh graduate cant even hve a job of rupess 10,000 just becoz he dont hve the experence and u want fresh and new faces to b with IK ?? education is necessary in politics but he shud also think and hve expericence like a politican our country is in crucial stage we cant take risks.

  • amir siddiqi

    well as long IK is not living luxuriously in London with the fear of getting killed while worrying about people of Karachi,when they are dying like roaches every day,he is not talking about one ethnicity and their grievances while whole Pakistan is a victim of corruption,i can take what ever you saw in that jalsah,which is not true for such a humble leader cz we sat with him on side walk in dust recently in sindh, while muhajirs are killing muhajirs within the party to prove their honesty and respect with a person,who is scared to even live among them.

  • MRK

    Dear All
    Interesting blog and comments.
    Its said in country like us that if you go to any gathering on time then ppl think that u’ve nothing to do or you’r so happy of becoming the special person(first time) that you come so early(exact time). IK, president of PTI, is he not Paki? so no prob.
    You cant expect anyone to be leader unless he doesnt have a convoy of personal guards. Blessing and trend of our society.
    PTI is because of IK, other leaders and workers of PTI are not renowed. So he need a bunch of some well know faces, and our bad luck is that we dont have a single politician who has good track record.
    But why we are always looking at darker sides and aspects, we are lively and brave nation, we are ready to give IK a chance too. After all we have been giving chance to Misbah ul Haq for so many yrs.
    God Bless

  • http://www.facebook.com/kaberdivel Junaid Ali

    hi ,sorry to all ,i am support IK,not just he is the only hope, other are also,but its not necessary but every one is right ,to day we see best Aeroplane, but no one know , how much we pay for it,problem are there, but IK is the only one ,how accept mistake, specially in his meeting,and hope u will find less mistake in next few jalsa, i must say pray for pakistan ,not pray for IK to become PM,

  • Usman

    As I do not agree most of your points but I fully endorsed your comments on MQM. IK would have been address this issue, but some lota poltiicans who joined him later, must have gave him some bad advices. MQM is a party of killers and IK’s alliance with MQM may drag him far away from the youth of Karachi. So I think instead of brining change in the country, IK himself, is changing.

  • Umarfarhan

    “please stop calling IK the last hope for Pakistan, believe me the world is not ending in 2012″
    this sentance is very beautiful. but i add one thing oher” Pakistan will remain untill the day of judgement (ameen)

thenews blog archive

Recent Bloggers

Syed Shahzad AlamSyed Shahzad Alam
A content developer at Jang Group of Companies...
Fatehullah KundiFatehullah Kundi
A freelancer and a student at the Deptartment of Civil Engineering. He can be r...
Farah KamalFarah Kamal
An education and development consultant with a masters degree from UBC-Canada an...
Hasnain IqbalHasnain Iqbal
The blogger contributes for The News/Geo blogs...
Madeeha IshtiaqueMadeeha Ishtiaque
The content writer & person-in-charge of the The News/Geo International Blog...
Afifa FaisalAfifa Faisal
A recent graduate of Master’s in Gender and Social Policy from the London Sch...
Riffat RashidRiffat Rashid
A freelance writer and a student at SZABIST's Media Science Program....
Mansoor RizviMansoor Rizvi
A contributor for The News/Geo blogs...
Write a blog
Most...

Poll

You can get jobs only ...

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Facebook Activity

Comments n Discussion